Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for educationHollingworth, Leta Stetter
Science
Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for education
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Educational psychology; Educational tests and measurements; Exceptional children
G was brought for mental tests because she did poorly in the school
where she was attending, receiving good marks in music and drawing only.
The difficulty in keeping up to grade in general was readily explained,
when the facts of school history were elicited. G was in a very
exclusive private school, where the median IQ of the pupils is about
120, instead of 100 as among unselected pupils. This child, on account
of the social status and educational traditions of her father’s family,
had been competing all her school life in a highly selected group of
children, and was now considered dull by teachers, by parents, and by
herself. All were astounded to learn of G’s average intellectual
capacity.
[Illustration:
FIG. 25.—Psychograph of G, showing special ability in music and
drawing. (Percentile values for speed in tapping, and strength of
grip have been approximated by estimate.)
]
It may be remarked in passing that this is the school history of many an
average child, born into a group where the family median is above the
average. The problems of the son of an eminent man, who fails to inherit
superior endowment and is but average in capacity, are especially acute,
for he is usually expected to undertake tasks for which he is
unqualified by original nature. The miseries of a boy of average
ability, expected from babyhood to pass through Harvard or Yale, the
distresses of a girl of ordinary intelligence, destined openly from
childhood for a college of very high standards, are peculiarly poignant
to the person who sees human nature in the light of all the facts which
we have been recounting. The case of G, and scores of others like it in
this respect, should lead parents to a policy of reticence concerning
their expectations of their children, until it is certain that these
expectations have a chance of being realized. Fortunately, the great
majority of children of very successful parents never have a problem of
this kind, because of the tendency to selective mating and the laws of
heredity. Most of the children of gifted parents are themselves
sufficiently gifted to perform the expected tasks as a matter of course.
Not all children of gifted fathers are, however, gifted, because other
ancestors, some of whom may be but average persons, are likely to
contribute to the mental status of the child. Yet according to the
customs of our country, it is usually the ability of the father that
determines the social _milieu_ and the educational tradition to which
the children are subject. Thus, the son of a corporation lawyer, who has
inherited the intelligence of a stupid but handsome grandmother and the
educational traditions of a brilliant father, is in a sorry plight,
unless the facts of human nature are expertly and sympathetically
understood in his family.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account