Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and CivilizationMumford, Lewis
History
Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and Civilization
Mumford, Lewis
Architecture -- United States
Nettled by the criticism that America was not Europe, the pioneer
determined to bring Europe to his doors. Relatively few American
architects during the period, however, had been abroad, and still
fewer had been there to any purpose; even men of culture and
imagination like Hawthorne and Emerson were not at home in the physical
environment of Europe, however intimate they were with its mind. The
buildings that were erected under the inspiration of European tours
only accentuated the barbarism of the American scene and the poverty of
the architect’s imagination.
A good part of our architecture today still exhibits the parvenu’s
uneasiness, and is by turns French, Italian, or more or less obsolete
English; but we do not, perhaps, realize with what a difference;
for photography and archæological research now make it possible to
produce buildings which have all the virtues of the original except
originality, whereas the earlier, illiterate development of foreign
examples, rehearsed in memory, resulted in a conglomerate form which
resembled nothing so much, perhaps, as P. T. Barnum’s mermaid.
If the Crystal Palace represents the extreme of industrial art, Colonel
Colt’s Armsmear represents the opposite--untutored romanticism.
Armsmear was built near Hartford, between 1855 and 1862. A writer in
the Art Journal for 1876 calls this mansion a “characteristic type
of the unique.” It was a “long, grand, impressive, contradictory,
beautiful, strange thing.... An Italian villa in stone, massive,
noble, refined, yet not carrying out any decided principles of
architecture, it is like the mind of its originator, bold and unusual
in its combinations.... There is no doubt it is a little Turkish among
other things, on one side it has domes, pinnacles, and light, lavish
ornamentation, such as Oriental taste delights in.... Yet, although
the villa is Italian and cosmopolitan, the feeling is English. It is
an English home in its substantiality, its home-like and comfortable
aspects.”
It is, alas! impossible to illustrate in these pages this remarkable
specimen of American architecture; but in a lecture on the Present
and Future Prospects of Chicago (1846), I have discovered its exact
literary equivalent, and it will sum up the crudity and cultural
wistfulness of the period perhaps better than any overt description:
“I thank you [apologizes the lecturer] for the patience you have
manifested on this occasion, and promise never more to offend in like
manner, so long. I have now, as Cowper observes--
‘Roved for fruit,
Roved far, and gathered much....’
“And can, I think with Scott, surely say that--
‘To his promise just
Vich-Alpine has discharged his trust.’
“I propose now, gentlemen, to leave you at Carlangtoghford,
‘And thou must keep thee with thy sword.’
“Let me say to you on this occasion, as Campbell does on another:
‘Wave, Munich! all your banners wave!
And charge with all your chivalry.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account