Studies in Classic American Literature — John Shaqi
Studies in Classic American LiteratureLawrence, D. H. (David Herbert)
History
Studies in Classic American Literature
Lawrence, D. H. (David Herbert)
American literature -- History and criticism
Since then Ford has gone one worse.
Through these white novels of Cooper runs this acid of ant-bites, the
formic acid of democratic poisoning. The Effinghams feel superior.
Cooper felt superior. Mrs. Cooper felt superior too. And bitten.
For they were democrats. They didn't believe in kings, or lords, or
masters, or real superiority of any sort. Before God, of course. In the
sight of God, of course, all men were equal. This they believed. And
therefore, though they _felt_ terribly superior to Mr. Dodge, yet, since
they were his equals in the sight of God, they could not feel free to
say to him: "Mr. Dodge, please go to the devil." They had to say:
"Pleased to meet you."
What a lie to tell! Democratic lies.
What a dilemma! To feel so superior. To _know_ you are superior. And yet
to believe that, in the sight of God, you are equal. Can't help
yourself.
Why couldn't they let the Lord Almighty look after the equality, since
it seems to happen specifically in His sight, and stick themselves to
their own superiority. Why couldn't they?
Somehow, they daren't.
They were Americans, idealists. How dare they balance a mere intense
feeling against an IDEA and an IDEAL?
Ideally--i. e., in the sight of God, Mr. Dodge was their equal.
What a low opinion they held of the Almighty's faculty for discrimination.
But it was so. The IDEAL of EQUALITY.
Pleased to meet you, Mr. Dodge.
We are equal in the sight of God, of course. But er--
Very glad to meet you. Miss Effingham. Did you say--_er?_ Well now, I
think my bank balance will bear it.
Poor Eve Effingham.
Eve! Think of it. Eve! And birds of paradise. And apples.
And Mr. Dodge.
This is where apples of knowledge get you, Miss Eve. You should leave
'em alone.
"Mr. Dodge, you are a hopeless and insufferable inferior."
Why couldn't she say it? She felt it. And she was a heroine.
Alas, she was an American heroine. She was an EDUCATED WOMAN. She KNEW
all about IDEALS. She swallowed the IDEAL of EQUALITY with her first
mouthful of KNOWLEDGE. Alas for her and that apple of Sodom that looked
so rosy. Alas for all her knowing.
Mr. Dodge (in check knickerbockers): Well, feeling a little
uncomfortable below the belt, are you, Miss Effingham?
Miss Effingham (with difficulty withdrawing her gaze from the INFINITE
OCEAN): Good morning, Mr. Dodge. I was admiring the dark blue distance.
Mr. Dodge: Say, couldn't you admire something a bit nearer.
Think how easy it would have been for her to say "Go away!" or "Leave
me, varlet!"--or "Hence, base-born knave!" Or just to turn her back on
him.
But then he would simply have marched round to the other side of her.
Was she his superior, or wasn't she?
Why surely, intrinsically, she _was._ Intrinsically Fenimore Cooper was
the superior of the Dodges of his day. He felt it. But he felt he ought
not to feel it. And he never had it out with himself.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account