Surgical Instruments in Greek and Roman TimesMilne, John Stewart
History
Surgical Instruments in Greek and Roman Times
Milne, John Stewart
Surgery -- History; Surgical instruments and apparatus
Aetius lived in the first half of the sixth century, and compiled a
voluminous treatise on medicine in sixteen books. He worked entirely with
scissors and paste, but the result is the preservation to us of a large
number of extracts from writers whose works would otherwise have entirely
disappeared, and his work is of great value for the study of instruments.
In 1534 an Aldine Edition of the first eight books was published, and,
though a translation of the whole work was published by Cornarius in
1533-42 in Latin, six of the last eight books were never published in the
original Greek. This is unfortunate for us, as for our purpose the
original is the only thing of any great value, Greek being, as I have
already pointed out, a language richer in compounds than Latin is, and
lending itself better to the coining of special names for special
instruments. Not that the sixteenth-century translator is ever at a loss
for a turn by which to express himself in Latin, but the turn, as often as
not, is by periphrasis just at the very point when we would have liked a
very exact equivalent for the Greek. The translation of the part of the
work of which we have the Greek shows that we cannot entirely depend on
some of these periphrases even where they appear definite, as in some
cases an unwarrantable assumption is made about the form of an instrument.
Thus λιθουλκῷ is translated 'forcipe ad id facta' because in Cornarius's
time the instrument used for extracting stone from the bladder was a
forceps, whereas it is doubtful whether there was in the Roman period
anything more than a scoop, and, therefore, we are not entitled to
translate λιθουλκός by anything more definite than 'stone extractor', its
etymological equivalent. Although, therefore, I have examined the latter
eight books of Aetius in the Latin translation, and although they contain
some of the most interesting information to be found in the whole work, I
have been very chary about laying stress on any deductions drawn from the
Latin translation only. It may be noted that there are two ways of
referring to the different books in Aetius, according to whether the Greek
text or the translation of Cornarius is meant. Cornarius arranged his
version in four tetrabibli of four books each, whereas the Greek text is
simply numbered from i-viii. 'No vii.' of the Greek text is, therefore,
called by Cornarius 'Tetr. ii. lib. iii.' The eleventh book was published
by Daremberg in his edition of Rufus (1879), and the twelfth book was
published by Costomeris at Paris in 1892.
Pliny the Younger. Plinius Secundus (Rose, Leipzig, 1875). The writings of
Pliny contain little information of any kind and are absolutely of no use
for our purpose.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account