Tantalus : $b or, The future of ManSchiller, F. C. S. (Ferdinand Canning Scott)
Philosophy
Tantalus : $b or, The future of Man
Schiller, F. C. S. (Ferdinand Canning Scott)
Civilization; Eugenics
It appears then that we can extract no guarantee of progress either
from the nature of Man or from the nature of human institutions. There
is no _law_ of progress, if by law be meant a superior power able to
coerce the creatures that are said to ‘obey’ it. Neither can we extract
from history any proof of the superiority of civilized man over his
uncivilized ancestors. Such progress as has been attained has been
achieved only by the active co-operation of the progressive organisms:
every step has been fought for, and progress has ceased whenever
effort ceased, or was switched off into different directions.
Consequently, modern man has no right to ‘boast himself far better
than his fathers’--in intrinsic quality. Intrinsically, _i.e._ apart
from the effects of culture and social training, it is probable that
he is slightly _inferior_ in capacity to his own ancestors, while
very markedly inferior to the great races of antiquity (like the
Greeks) in their hey-day. Nor is there any reason to suppose that his
moral nature has changed materially. Modern man may be a little tamer
and better-tempered, because he has been herded together much more
closely than primitive man, and city life, even in slums, demands,
and produces, a certain ‘urbanity.’ For many generations those who
would not pack tight and could not stand the strain of constantly
exhibiting ‘company manners’ and accommodating their action to those
of their fellows, must have fled away into the wilds, where they could
be independent, or have eliminated themselves in other ways, _e.g._ by
committing murder. It is probable that the social history of Iceland,
settled as it was by unbridled individualists who would not brook any
form of organized government, might throw some light on this process of
taming the individual.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account