Tantalus : $b or, The future of ManSchiller, F. C. S. (Ferdinand Canning Scott)
Philosophy
Tantalus : $b or, The future of Man
Schiller, F. C. S. (Ferdinand Canning Scott)
Civilization; Eugenics
Nevertheless there is little doubt that, in the main, humanity is
still Yahoo-manity. Alike in mentality and in _moral_, modern man is
still substantially identical with his palæolithic ancestors. He is
still the irrational, impulsive, emotional, foolish, destructive,
cruel, credulous, creature he always was. Normally the Yahoo in him
is kept under control by the constant pressure of a variety of social
institutions; but let anything upset an established social order, and
the Yahoo comes to the front at once. The history of the past fifty
years abundantly proves that man is still capable of atrocities equal
to any in his record. Not only have we lived through the greatest
political and the deadliest natural convulsion, the Great War and the
Tokio earthquake, but the Russian Revolution has outdone the French and
Landru the legendary Bluebeard, while for mingled atrocity and baseness
the murders of Rasputin and of Alexander of Serbia are unsurpassed in
history. The painful truth is that civilization has not improved Man’s
moral nature. His moral habits are still mainly matters of custom, and
the effect of moral theories is nugatory everywhere. Thus civilization
is not even skin deep; it does not go deeper than the clothes.
V
Clearly it is risky to expose the inelastic nature of so stubbornly
conservative a creature to new conditions at a rapid rate. He may not
be able to adapt himself quickly enough, and his old reactions, which
did little or no harm before, may become extremely dangerous. Yet this
is just what has happened. Science has exposed the palæolithic savage
masquerading in modern garb to a series of physical and mental shocks
which have endangered his equilibrium. It has also enormously extended
his power and armed him with a variety of delicate and penetrating
instruments which have often proved edge tools in his hands and which
the utmost wisdom could hardly be trusted to use aright. Under these
conditions the fighting instinct ceases to be an antiquated foible,
like the hunting instinct, and becomes a deadly danger. No wonder the
more prescient are dismayed at the prospect of the old savage passions
running amok in the full panoply of civilization!
VI
Nor is this the final item in our tale of woe. A third and most
sinister fact which has to be faced is that Civilization, as at present
constituted, is very definitely a deteriorating agency, conducing to
the degeneration of mankind. This effect of Civilization is nothing
new, but has been operating, it would seem, from the beginning,
though not probably as intensively as now: its discovery, however, is
very recent. It is quite indirect, unintended, and fortuitous, but
cumulative, and in the long run has probably been a chief cause in the
decay of States and civilizations, as well as an important factor in
the arrest of biological development which we have had to recognize.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account