The accomplishment ratio : $b A treatment of the inherited determinants of disparity in school product — John Shaqi
The accomplishment ratio : $b A treatment of the inherited determinants of disparity in school productFranzen, Raymond
Science
The accomplishment ratio : $b A treatment of the inherited determinants of disparity in school product
Franzen, Raymond
Ability -- Testing; Educational psychology; Educational tests and measurements
We have noted that it is very difficult to understand what the neural
bases for such special abilities as Galton speaks of could be; that
they are social, not neural or psychological units. A view of a large
number of inherited elements all of which contribute to what we call
general intelligence and each of which is slightly more necessary to
some vocation than others, would account for all the observed facts, is
neurally imaginable, and does not need to view ability to be a “judge”
or “artistic talents” as biological entities. It further explains the
differences in their limited abilities of mentally deficient children.
Burt says in this connection: “Among children of special (M.D.) schools,
the evidence for a general factor underlying educational abilities and
disabilities of every kind is not so clear. In administrative practice,
‘mental deficiency’ implies among different children deficiencies in
very different capacities, both general and specific.” (Cyril Burt: _The
Distribution and Relation of Educational Abilities_, p. 83.)
For these reasons it is justifiable to attempt to present evidence
of the inheritance of school abilities with a view to showing that
school abilities are not dependent upon special inherited aptitudes,
as teachers so often assume, but that general intelligence is the only
inherited cause of disparity in product. Investigations where the
correlation between educational product and intelligence, irrespective
of chronological age, was less than around .75, used data where many
removable causes were not removed, and consequently measured results of
the environment as well as heredity. A case such as this follows:
“The influence of inheritance upon a _very specific_ mental quality,
namely, spelling ability, has been tested experimentally, although here
there is some difficulty in separating the influence of heredity from
that of environment. Earle studied the spelling ability of 180 pairs
of brothers and sisters who had uniform school training and found a
correlation of .50. This means that if one child deviated by a certain
amount from the average child in spelling ability, his brother or sister
would deviate from the average child just half as much; that is, he
would resemble his brother or sister to that extent.” (Hollingworth and
Poffenberger: _Applied Psychology_, p. 44.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account