The Ancient Volcanoes of Great Britain, Volume 1 (of 2)Geikie, Archibald
History
The Ancient Volcanoes of Great Britain, Volume 1 (of 2)
Geikie, Archibald
Volcanoes -- Great Britain
Fortunately for the progress of natural knowledge, Werner disliked the
manual labour of penmanship. Consequently he wrote little. But his
wide range of acquirement, not in mineralogy only, his precision of
statement, his absolute certainty about the truth of his own opinions,
and his hardly disguised contempt for opinions that differed from them,
combined with his enthusiasm, eloquence and personal charm, fired
his pupils with emulation of his zeal and turned them into veritable
propagandists. Misled as to the structure of the country in which
their master taught, and undisciplined to investigate nature with an
impartial mind, they travelled into other lands for the purpose of
applying there the artificial system which they had learnt at Freiberg.
The methodical but cumbrous terminology in which Werner had trained
them was translated by them into their own languages, where it looked
still more uncouth than in its native German. Besides imbibing their
teacher's system, they acquired and even improved upon his somewhat
disdainful manner towards all conclusions different from those of the
Saxon Mining School.
Such was the spirit in which the pupils of Werner proceeded to set the
"geognosy" of Europe to rights. The views, announced by Desmarest,
that various rocks, far removed from any active volcano, were yet of
volcanic origin, had been slowly gaining ground when the militant
students from Saxony spread themselves over the Continent. These views,
however, being irreconcilable with the tenets enunciated from the
Freiberg Chair, were now either ignored or contemptuously rejected.
Werner's disciples loved to call themselves by their teacher's term
"geognosts," and claimed that they confined themselves to the strict
investigation of fact with regard to the structure of the earth, in
apparent unconsciousness that their terminology and methods were
founded on baseless assumptions and almost puerile hypotheses.
With such elements ready for controversy, it was no wonder that before
long a battle arose over the origin of basalt and the part played by
volcanoes in the past history of the globe. The disciples of Werner,
champions of a universal ocean and the deposition of everything from
water, were dubbed Neptunists, while their opponents, equally stubborn
in defence of the potency of volcanic fire, were known as Vulcanists or
Plutonists. For more than a generation this futile warfare was waged
with extraordinary bitterness--dogmatism and authority doing their best
to stop the progress of impartial observation and honest opinion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account