F. W. Dixon: I find it rather a shy bearer, but the tree is long-lived and very hardy, and it deserves a place in the family orchard. I think there is no profit in them for a commercial orchard. President Wellhouse: They are long-lived and very hardy; I would recommend them for family, but not for commercial orchard. G. P. Whiteker: It comes at a time when there is much other fruit. I do not think it pays very well. Mine turn brown from some cause. Phillip Lux: It is our very best apple in its season; while talking of the commercial orchard, there is a demand for apples at all seasons of the year, and if we discard this, we will have nothing at its season. I would say, place it in the commercial orchard for export. W. J. Griffing: Do not know that it is profitable, but for quality the Maiden's Blush is worthy of a place among fruits. G. W. Bailey: As a summer apple for family and commercial orchards, I would place it at the head of the list. William Cutter: It is the best apple of its season for all purposes. B. F. Smith: It is the best commercial apple for summer trade we have. Secretary Barnes: At the late meeting of the Missouri Horticultural Society, the secretary stated that he thought there was good money in the Maiden's Blush. He said the trouble was, they were raised in too limited quantities. He said they should be raised in car lots for shipping to Northern cities; that they were quick growers and brought ready money, and at their season had little competition in the market. They come in when there are few apples obtainable, and he considers them profitable. H. L. Ferris: In my experience it bears only every other year. Is that the experience of others? President Wellhouse: The Maiden's Blush is the only summer apple that we have made pay. J. W. Robison: We have not grown Maiden's Blush very largely here. It is one of our old apples in Illinois, and it is the earliest, most regular and profuse bearer, and the best keeper of its season to ship in hot weather. It was named for its beauty, and is the most attractive apple grown. They last well if kept moderately cool. They are shipped largely in barrels, the earlier ones in boxes, from central Illinois north. The tree is tender in unusually cold seasons. Farther south there is no danger. I find it is a good apple to sell in a small way to grocerymen. GRIMES'S GOLDEN PIPPIN. _Synonym_: Grimes's Golden.