Arabs -- Folklore; Fairy tales -- Arab countries; Tales -- Arab countries
Of the tales themselves, I do not mean to enter into a long and
minute investigation; although such an investigation would be, if
well conducted, highly amusing, and at the same time instructive.
But to carry on an inquiry of this sort, to the extent it ought,
would require great research and labour, and would in itself form a
separate work. Mr. Hole has even produced a small volume in the
illustration only of one story, which occupies not more than the
fifth part of one volume of the present tales. All the peculiarities
and customs, which are mentioned in the Arabian Nights, might be
illustrated by similar peculiarities and customs, which are not only
known to have existed among the very people, of whom this work
delineates the manners, at the very time when the work itself was
composed, but which also still exist among the same nations. Such an
inquiry too would tend to explain some parts of the present work,
which must, without it, now appear, if not absurd, at least
unaccountable. To shew, however, that even the most common things
are not inserted without a motive, and to illustrate what might be
otherwise considered as ridiculous, I shall give one or two
instances of the manner of investigation and sort of illustration
proposed.
In the story of the Merchant and Genius, Vol. I. page 29, the latter
says, “I have sworn to kill thee, as thou hast killed my son; for
whilst thou was throwing about the stones of the dates thou hadst
eaten, my son passed by, and one of them struck him in the eye and
caused his death.” Now this, at first sight, seems a singular, if
not a ridiculous thing; but even this has its foundation in an
Eastern custom. There are accounts (and I speak upon the authority
of Warren Hastings, Esq. than whom no one is better acquainted with
Oriental manners and history; and whose name is almost reverenced
throughout that quarter of the world,) there are accounts of people
having been killed by date stones, which were shot at them in a
particular manner with both hands. Those persons who are in the
habit of doing this, will send the stone with such velocity as to
give a most violent blow. And it is in this manner that prisoners
have sometimes been put to death: a man sits down at a little
distance from the object he intends to destroy, and then attacks him
by repeatedly shooting at him with the stone of the date, thrown
from his two fore-fingers; and in this way puts an end to his life.
--The former translation, by calling these stones, the “shells”
of the date, besides totally mistaking the fact, dates having no
shells but only stones, makes complete nonsense of the tale.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account