The Art of Logical Thinking; Or, The Laws of Reasoning — John Shaqi
The Art of Logical Thinking; Or, The Laws of ReasoningAtkinson, William Walker
Philosophy
The Art of Logical Thinking; Or, The Laws of Reasoning
Atkinson, William Walker
Logic; Reasoning
A close study of these relations, and the symbols expressing them, is
necessary for a clear comprehension of the Laws of Opposition stated a
little further back, as well as the principles of Conversion which we
shall mention a little further on. The following chart, called the
Square of Opposition, is also employed by logicians to illustrate the
relations between the four classes of propositions:
A CONTRARIES E
+------------------------+
|\ / |
| \ /S |
| C\ /E |
| O\ /I |
| N\ /R |
| T\ /O |
S| R\ /T |S
U| A\ /C |U
B| \ /I |B
A| \ /D |A
L| \ / |L
T| / \ |T
E| / D\ |E
R| / I\ |R
N| /A C\ |N
S| /R T\ |S
| /T O\ |
| /N R\ |
| /O I\ |
| /C E\ |
| / S\ |
|/ \ |
+------------------------+
I SUB-CONTRARIES O
_Conversion_ is the process of immediate reasoning by which we infer
from a given proposition another proposition having the predicate of
the original for its subject and the subject of the original for its
predicate; or stated in a few words: _Conversion is the transposition of
the subject and predicate of a proposition_. As Brooks states it:
"Propositions or judgments are _converted_ when the subject and
predicate change places in such a manner that the resulting judgment is
an inference from the given judgment." The new proposition, resulting
from the operation or Conversion, is called the Converse; the original
proposition is called the Convertend.
_The Law of Conversion_ is that: "No term must be distributed in the
Converse that is not distributed in the Convertend." This arises from
the obvious fact that nothing should be affirmed in the derived
proposition than there is in the original proposition.
There are three kinds of Conversion; _viz_: (1) Simple Conversion; (2)
Conversion by Limitation; (3) Conversion by Contraposition.
In _Simple Conversion_ there is no change in either quality or quantity.
In _Conversion by Limitation_ the quality is changed from universal to
particular. In Conversion by Negation the quality is changed but not
the quantity. Referring to the classification tables and symbols given
in the preceding pages of this chapter, we may now proceed to consider
the application of these methods of Conversion to each of the four kinds
of propositions; as follows:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account