The Art of Logical Thinking; Or, The Laws of ReasoningAtkinson, William Walker
Philosophy
The Art of Logical Thinking; Or, The Laws of Reasoning
Atkinson, William Walker
Logic; Reasoning
_The Universal Affirmative_ (symbol A) proposition is converted by
Limitation, or by a change of quality from universal to particular. The
predicate not being "distributed" in the convertend, we must not
distribute it in the converse by saying "_all_." Thus in this case we
must convert the proposition, "all men are mortal" (A), into "some
mortals are men" (I).
_The Universal Negative_ (symbol E) is converted by Simple Conversion,
in which there is no change in either quality or quantity. For since
both terms of "E" are distributed, they may both be distributed in the
converse without violating the law of conversion. Thus "No man is
mortal" is converted into: "No mortals are men." "E" is converted into
"E."
_The Particular Affirmative_ (symbol I) is also converted by Simple
Conversion in which there is no change in either quality or quantity.
For since neither term is distributed in "I," neither term may be
distributed in the converse, and the latter must remain "I." For
instance; the proposition: "Some men are mortal" is converted into the
proposition, "Some mortals are men."
_The Particular Negative_ (symbol O) is converted by Conversion by
Negation, in which the quality is changed but not the quantity. Thus in
converting the proposition: "Some men are not mortal," we must _not_ say
"some mortals are not men," for in so doing we would distribute _men_ in
the predicate, where it is not distributed in the convertend. Avoiding
this, _we transfer the negative particle from the copula to the
predicate_ so that the convertend becomes "I" which is converted by
Simple Conversion. Thus we transfer "Some men are not mortal" into "Some
men are not-mortal" from which we easily convert (by simple Conversion)
the proposition: "Some not-mortals are men."
It will be well for students, at this point, to consider the three
following Fundamental Laws of Thought as laid down by the authorities,
which are as follows:
_The Law of Identity_, which states that: "The same quality or thing is
always the same quality or thing, no matter how different the conditions
in which it occurs."
_The Law of Contradiction_, which states that: "No thing can at the same
time and place both be and not be."
_The Law of Excluded Middle_, which states that: "Everything must either
be or not be; there is no other alternative or middle course."
Of these laws, Prof. Jevons, a noted authority, says: "Students are
seldom able to see at first their full meaning and importance. All
arguments may be explained when these self-evident laws are granted; and
it is not too much to say that the whole of logic will be plain to those
who will constantly use these laws as the key."
CHAPTER XI.
INDUCTIVE REASONING
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account