The Atlantic Monthly, Volume 16, No. 95, September 1865: A Magazine of Literature, Art, and PoliticsVarious
General
The Atlantic Monthly, Volume 16, No. 95, September 1865: A Magazine of Literature, Art, and Politics
Various
American periodicals
This, then, is the task at which Goethe toiled for many an earnest year.
He will read through world to man, and through all man's fortunes,
inward and outward, to the complete constitution and perfect
architectures of his spirit. Let him succeed in that, and the word of
words for our century and for many centuries is spoken. "Positive
philosophy," with complacent sciolism, may still coldly asseverate that
the world is a dead congeries of "laws," into whose realm man is cast to
take pot-luck in the universe; but we shall know better. The worldling
may still find all good and all evil in the mere fortunes of man; we
shall see beyond these. The fatalist may persist in regarding limits and
conditions as the all in all of life; we shall see them as a foothold
for growth. Once that the spirit of man appears as the final recipient
and vessel of uses, the orderly emptiness of world-law is filled with a
meaning, while the wild welter of man's fortunes and the rigid fixity of
his conditions find alike sufficing centre around which their orbit is
drawn.
Observe, however, that we have here no piece of system-making. Goethe
does not attempt a final scientific theory of existence. He _pictures_
life from this point of view. If you can feel the verity in this
picture, you may then feel the same verity in that picture which Another
has painted, namely, in life itself.
Observe, once more, that even here life is depicted only from _one_ of
its two poles, and that, perhaps, the lesser. The theme is Growth, and
this growth is considered as proceeding from definite elements contained
in man's being, and proceeding to definite results still contained in
his being. "Faust" assumes the opposite pole. Its theme is Destiny. It
regards man's life as sweeping down upon him from heights above his
thought, and proceeding to ends beyond his imagination. His existence
appears as fashioned in essence and end by predestinating power, and the
Eternal "takes the responsibility."
The artist must choose his point of view. It is impossible to paint the
house at once from the inside and from the outside. "Faust" is properly
an epic poem; "Wilhelm Meister" is a prose epic,--and prose, not from
lack of metre, but precisely from its point of view. It treats life, not
as proceeding from the bosom and moving to the ends of benign Destiny,
but as contained in thought, will, character, aspiration, love, and as
contingent, rather than eternally predestined, in its result. Much of
religious grandeur, therefore,--to the great disgust of Novalis,--it
loses; much of economic value it gains. A prose picture: yet even here
we read through all else to man, and through all else in man himself to
the upbuilding of his spirit. As Goethe reads life, let us see if we can
read his book.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account