The Birth of Civilization in the Near EastFrankfort, Henri
History
The Birth of Civilization in the Near East
Frankfort, Henri
Civilization, Ancient; Egypt -- Antiquities; Iraq -- Antiquities; Middle East -- Civilization -- To 622
[179]See Frankfort, “The Origin of Monumental Architecture in
Egypt,” in _American Journal of Semitic Languages and Literatures_,
LVIII (1941), 329-58. In this article we have not only discussed the
detailed technical similarities between recessed brick building in
the two countries but also demonstrated the inadequacy of prevalent
explanations of the Egyptian examples, “irrespective the fact that
they failed to account for the contemporary construction of similar
buildings in Mesopotamia.”
[180]This does not imply that they must have been mean structures.
In Uganda, for instance, no fewer than a thousand men are
continuously engaged in the royal enclosure on building and repairs
(John Roscoe, _The Baganda_, 366).
[181]See also Borchardt, “Das Grab des Menes,” in _Zeitschrift für
Aegyptische Sprache_, XXXVI (1898), 87-105.
[182]This is the _Riemchenverband_, observed by the excavators of
Erech (E. Heinrich, _Schilf und Lehm_, 40) and of Tell Asmar
(Delougaz and Lloyd, _Pre-Sargonid Temples in the Diyala Region_
[Chicago, 1942], 169, Fig. 127).
[183]In our figure and in the tomb of Neithotep (“Das Grab des
Menes”—see n. 2, above), the structures, like the Babylonian
temples, appear to stand on a brick platform; but in reality a low
revetment was built up against the outside of the walls after these
had been built up—complete with recesses—from the foundations. In
Babylonia this apparent platform is called a _kisu_.
[184]Our Fig. 48 shows the impressions of these round timbers in the
brick work of the White Temple at Erech, of which Fig. 45 shows the
plan. Fig. 49 shows a wooden sarcophagus found in a First Dynasty
tomb at Tarkhan in Egypt, which imitates a recessed building with a
similar strengthening of round timbers. Fig. 50 shows an actual tomb
found at Abu Roash in Lower Egypt with some timbers still in place.
[185]The Egyptian designs (Figs. 42, 44 left, 43) are supposed to
render a palace façade, an assumption incapable of proof and
ignoring the fact that the tombs have recesses on all four sides.
But whatever the original of this design may have been, its
abbreviated rendering in Egypt resembles an abbreviated rendering of
temples in Mesopotamia (Fig. 44 right) very closely.
[186]At Abydos three of these, perhaps built under the Second
Dynasty, survive. See Petrie, _Abydos_, III (London, 1904), Plates
V-VIII.
[187]Scharff, _Archaeologische Beiträge zur Frage der Entstehung der
Hieroglyphenschrift_ (München, 1942).
[188]See _Kingship and the Gods_, 20 and 350, n. 15.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account