The Campaign of Waterloo: A Military History: Third EditionRopes, John Codman
History
The Campaign of Waterloo: A Military History: Third Edition
Ropes, John Codman
Napoleon I, Emperor of the French, 1769-1821 -- Elba and the Hundred Days, 1814-1815; Waterloo, Battle of, Waterloo, Belgium, 1815
“All writers who have treated of this campaign set out by saying
that Buonaparte threw himself between the two armies, in order to
separate them. This expression, however, which has become a _terminus
technicus_ in military phraseology, has no clear idea for its
foundation. The space intervening between two armies cannot be an
object of operation.[11] It would have been very unfortunate if a
commander like Buonaparte, having to deal with an enemy of twice his
force, instead of falling on the one half with his united strength,
had lighted on the empty interval, and thus made a blow in the air,
losing his time, whilst he can only double his own force by the
strictest economy of that commodity. Even the fighting the one army
in a direction by which it will be pressed away from the other, even
if it can be effected without loss of time, incurs the great danger
of being attacked in the rear by the other. If the latter, therefore,
be not far enough removed to put this risk out of the question, a
commander will scarcely venture on such a line of attack. Buonaparte,
therefore, chose the direction between the two armies, _not in order
to separate them by wedging himself between_,[12] but because he
expected to find and fall on Blücher’s force in this direction,
either united or in separate bodies [corps].” _Feldzug von 1815_,
&c., p. 54:[13]
* * * * * * * *
His main object was evidently to find the Prussian army, and beat it.”
Nevertheless we find Hooper,[14] who wrote long after Clausewitz, making
the very statement which Clausewitz thought so objectionable:—
“He (Napoleon) calculated that if he struck at the centre of the two
armies he should be able _to wedge himself in between them_, crushing
any divisions which attempted to obstruct his progress, and, having
won a position of vantage, he imagined that it would be in his power
to manœuvre with rapidity from side to side and defeat each army in
succession.”
To the same effect writes Quinet:—
“He (Napoleon) will place himself between the two armies, at the
centre of the line, that is to say, at the extreme right of the
Prussian cantonments. By this move, the Duke of Wellington and
Marshal Blücher will be separated from the first hour. The occasion,
the moment, will decide on which of the two armies it will be best to
strike the first blow.”[15]
It is unnecessary to repeat what has been so well said above in
opposition to this view. It is plain that these writers have
misconceived Napoleon’s plan. But we must consider this more fully.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account