The Causes of the Corruption of the Traditional Text of the Holy Gospels: Being the Sequel to The Traditional Text of the Holy GospelsBurgon, John William
Religion
The Causes of the Corruption of the Traditional Text of the Holy Gospels: Being the Sequel to The Traditional Text of the Holy Gospels
Burgon, John William
Bible. Gospels -- Criticism, Textual
Trad. Text. A (with [Greek: eremon topon]) C + twelve Uncials,
all Cursives except three or five, Harkleian, Lewis (omits
[Greek: eremon]), Ethiopic, Armenian, Gothic, with Theophylact
(i. 33).
Remark the curious character of [Symbol: alpha] and [Symbol: beta]. In
Dr. Hort's Neutral Text, which he maintains to have been the original
text of the Gospels, our Lord is represented here as having withdrawn in
private ([Greek: kat' idian], which the Revisers shirking the difficulty
translate inaccurately 'apart') _into the city called Bethsaida_. How
could there have been privacy of life _in_ a city in those days? In
fact, [Greek: kat' idian] necessitates the adoption of [Greek: topon
eremon], as to which the Peshitto ([Symbol: beta]^{3}) is in substantial
agreement with the Traditional Text. Bethsaida is represented as the
capital of a district, which included, at sufficient distance from the
city, a desert or retired spot. The group arranged under [Symbol: beta]
is so weakly supported, and is evidently such a group of fragments, that
it can come into no sort of competition with the Traditional reading.
Dr. Hort confines himself to shewing _how_ the process he advocates
might have arisen, not _that_ it did actually arise. Indeed, this
position can only be held by assuming the conclusion to be established
that it _did_ so arise.
(6) St. Luke xi. 54. 'The Scribes and Pharisees began to urge Him
vehemently and to provoke Him to speak of many things ([Greek:
enedreuontes thereusai]),
[Symbol: alpha]. Laying wait for Him to catch something out of
His mouth.
[Symbol: beta]. Seeking to get some opportunity ([Greek:
aphormen tina]) for finding out how to accuse Him ([Greek: hina
eurosin kategoresai]); or, for accusing Him ([Greek: hina
kategoresosin autou]).
Trad. Text. Laying wait for Him, _and_ seeking to catch
something ([Greek: zetountes thereusai ti]) out of His mouth,
that they might accuse Him.'
The evidence is--
[Symbol: alpha]. [Symbol: Aleph]BL, Bohairic, Ethiopic, Cyril
Alex. (Mai, Nov. Pp. Bibliotheca, ii. 87, iii. 249, not
accurately).
[Symbol: beta]. D, Old Latin except f, Curetonian.
Trad. Text. AC + twelve Uncials, all Cursives (except five which
omit [Greek: zetountes]), Peshitto, Lewis (with omission),
Vulgate, Harkleian, Theophylact (i. 363).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account