The collected works of Henrik Ibsen, Vol. 01 (of 11) — John Shaqi
The collected works of Henrik Ibsen, Vol. 01 (of 11)Ibsen, Henrik
General
The collected works of Henrik Ibsen, Vol. 01 (of 11)
Ibsen, Henrik
Ibsen, Henrik, 1828-1906 -- Translations into English; Norwegian drama -- Translations into English
indeed generous, critic finds in it “a curious example of perhaps
inevitable inadequacy.... ‘Duty! Duty! Duty!’ Hilda once exclaims in
a scornful outburst. ‘What a short, sharp, stinging word!’ The
epithets do not seem specially apt. But in the original she cries
out ‘Pligt! Pligt! Pligt!’ and the very word stings and snaps.” I
submit that in this criticism there is one superfluous word—to wit,
the “perhaps” which qualifies “inevitable.” For the term used by
Hilda, and for the idea in her mind, there is only one possible
English equivalent: “Duty.” The actress can speak it so as more or
less to justify Hilda’s feeling towards it; and, for the rest, the
audience must “piece out our imperfections with their thoughts” and
assume that the Norwegian word has rather more of a sting in its
sound. It might be possible, no doubt, to adapt Hilda’s phrase to
the English word, and say, “It sounds like the swish of a whip
lash,” or something to that effect. But this is a sort of freedom
which, rightly or wrongly, I hold inadmissible. Once grant the right
of adaptation, even in small particulars, and it would be impossible
to say where it should stop. The versions here presented (of the
prose plays, at any rate) are translations, not paraphrases. If we
have ever dropped into paraphrase, it is a dereliction of principle;
and I do not remember an instance. For stage purposes, no doubt, a
little paring of rough edges is here and there allowable; but even
that, I think, should seldom go beyond the omission of lines which
manifestly lose their force in translation, or are incomprehensible
without a footnote.
In the Introductions to previous editions I have always confined
myself to the statement of biographical and historic facts, holding
criticism no part of my business. Now that Henrik Ibsen has passed
away, and his works have taken a practically uncontested place in
world-literature, this reticence seemed no longer imposed upon me. I
have consequently made a few critical remarks on each play, chiefly
directed towards tracing the course of the poet’s technical
development. Nevertheless, the Introductions are still mainly
biographical, and full advantage has been taken of the stores of new
information contained in Ibsen’s Letters, and in the books and
articles about him that have appeared since his death. I have
prefixed to _Lady Inger of Östråt_ a sketch of the poet’s life down
to the date of that play; so that the Introductions, read in
sequence, will be found to form a pretty full record of a career
which, save for frequent changes of domicile, and the issuing of
play after play, was singularly uneventful.
The Introductions to _Loves Comedy_ and _Brand_, as well as the
translations, are entirely the work of Professor Herford.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account