The collected works of Henrik Ibsen, Vol. 01 (of 11)Ibsen, Henrik
General
The collected works of Henrik Ibsen, Vol. 01 (of 11)
Ibsen, Henrik
Ibsen, Henrik, 1828-1906 -- Translations into English; Norwegian drama -- Translations into English
With two exceptions, the plays appear in their chronological order.
The exceptions are _Love’s Comedy_, which ought by rights to come
between _The Vikings_ and _The Pretenders_, and _Emperor and
Galilean_, which ought to follow _The League of Youth_ instead of
preceding it. The reasons of convenience which prompted these
departures from the exact order are pretty obvious. It seemed highly
desirable to bring the two Saga Plays, if I may so call them, into
one volume; while as for _Emperor and Galilean_, it could not have
been placed between _The League of Youth_ and _Pillars of Society_
save by separating its two parts, and assigning _Caesar’s Apostasy_
to Volume V., _The Emperor Julian_ to Volume VI.
For the translations of all the plays in this edition, except
_Love’s Comedy_ and _Brand_, I am ultimately responsible, in the
sense that I have exercised an unrestricted right of revision. This
means, of course, that, in plays originally translated by others,
the merits of the English version belong for the most part to the
original translator, while the faults may have been introduced, and
must have been sanctioned, by me. The revision, whether fortunate or
otherwise, has in all cases been very thorough.
In their unrevised form, these translations have met with a good
deal of praise and with some blame. I trust that the revision has
rendered them more praiseworthy, but I can scarcely hope that it has
met all the objections of those critics who have found them
blameworthy. For, in some cases at any rate these objections
proceeded from theories of the translator’s function widely
divergent from my own—theories of which nothing, probably, could
disabuse the critic’s mind, save a little experience of the
difficulties of translating (as distinct from adapting) dramatic
prose. Ibsen is at once extremely easy and extremely difficult to
translate. It is extremely easy, in his prose plays, to realise his
meaning; it is often extremely difficult to convey it in natural,
colloquial, and yet not too colloquial, English. He is especially
fond of laying barbed-wire entanglements for the translator’s feet,
in the shape of recurrent phrases for which it is absolutely
impossible to find an equivalent that will fit in all the different
contexts. But this is only one of many classes of obstacles which
encountered us on almost every page. I think, indeed, that my
collaborators and I may take it as no small compliment that some of
our critics have apparently not realised the difficulties of our
task, or divined the laborious hours which have often gone to the
turning of a single phrase. And, in not a few cases, the
difficulties have proved sheer impossibilities. I will cite only one
instance. Writing of _The Master Builder_, a very competent, and
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account