The Commune of London, and other studiesRound, John Horace
History
The Commune of London, and other studies
Round, John Horace
Great Britain -- History -- Norman period, 1066-1154; London (England) -- History -- To 1500
Backed (_sic_) by the disorderly There the house carles of King
masses of the fyrd, and by the Harold, backed (_sic_) by the
thegns of the home counties, thegnhood of all southern
the house carles of King Harold England and the disorderly
stood (‘Art of War,’ p. 24). masses of the fyrd of the home
counties, drew themselves out
(‘Social England,’ p. 229).
In perfect agreement with these passages, I hold that “the well-armed
house carles,” as Mr. Oman terms them, formed the English front, and
were “backed” by the rest of the host.[101] Mr. Oman’s later view
involves a tactical absurdity, as I have maintained throughout.[102]
But here again Mr. Oman finds it the safest plan to ignore an argument
he cannot face.
Let me, however, part from his narrative of the great struggle with
an expression of honest satisfaction that, even in his latest work,
he treats “the English host” as ranged “in one great solid mass”
(p. 154). This is the essential point on which I have insisted
throughout.[103] “No feature of the great battle is more absolutely
beyond dispute”;[104] and it absolutely cuts the ground from under Mr.
Archer’s feet.[105]
I may add that the denseness of the English host is similarly grasped
by Sir James Ramsay, who has made an independent examination of the
battle, and has set forth his interesting and original conclusions in
his recently-published ‘Foundations of England.’ The ground plan of
the battle in his work should be carefully compared with that which is
found in Mr. Freeman’s History. For the two differ so hopelessly that
the wholly conjectural character of Mr. Freeman’s views on the matter
will at once be vividly shown. The bold conclusion of Sir James Ramsay
that the English host held only the little plateau at the summit of the
Battle hill, is at least in harmony with their dense array, and is very
possibly correct.[106]
* * * * *
I now turn from battles to castles--those castles which played so
prominent a part in Anglo-Norman warfare.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account