The Criticism of the Fourth Gospel: Eight Lectures on the Morse Foundation, Delivered in the Union Seminary, New York in October and November 1904Sanday, W. (William)
Religion
The Criticism of the Fourth Gospel: Eight Lectures on the Morse Foundation, Delivered in the Union Seminary, New York in October and November 1904
Sanday, W. (William)
Bible. John -- Criticism, interpretation, etc.
In looking back over a distant past it is always difficult to keep the
true perspective; the mind is apt to forget, or at least to foreshorten,
the process by which its beliefs have been reached; and when once a
settled conviction has been formed it is treated as though it had been
present from the beginning. It would have been strange indeed if the
aged disciple had nowhere allowed the cherished beliefs of more than
half a lifetime to colour the telling of his story, or to project
themselves backwards into those early days when his faith was not as yet
ripe but only ripening. It would not in the least disturb our conclusion
to admit, that in the earlier chapters of the Gospel there are a number
of expressions that are heightened in character and more definite in
form than those that were really used.
i. Anticipated Confessions.
What has just been said will apply especially to the terms in which the
first disciples who gathered round our Lord are described as giving in
their adhesion. The author of the Gospel was himself a convinced
Christian—a Christian so convinced that he could hardly recall the time
when he had been anything else. It was natural to him to think of his
comrades in the faith as he thought of himself. And if he puts into
their mouths stronger expressions than they actually used, it was only a
little antedating the fact.
But, apart from this, it is a question whether we ourselves do not read
into the words more than they really contain. There can be no doubt that
the half-century, or rather more, before the fall of Jerusalem was a
time of high-strung expectation on the part of the Jews. The belief that
the Messiah was about to appear was widely diffused among all classes of
the people. It was this belief which gave a transient success to the
many pretenders of whom we read in the Acts and in the pages of
Josephus. There was the feeling that the Messiah might come at any
moment, and no Jew would have been surprised if He had appeared in his
own immediate neighbourhood. Vague rumours were everywhere about, and we
may be sure would readily attach themselves to individuals. It is
probable enough that among the crowds which gathered round the Baptist
this expectation was even more rife than elsewhere. Those who came to
his baptism, we may well believe, were among the most earnest, the most
patriotic, and the most sanguine spirits of the nation. That little
groups, united by local ties, would be readily formed, and readily seek
to attach themselves to one who seemed to possess the qualities of a
leader, would be only what we should expect. And if their enthusiasm was
easily aroused, that would be all in harmony with their surroundings.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account