The Delinquent, Vol. IV, No. 6, June, 1914 — John Shaqi
The Delinquent, Vol. IV, No. 6, June, 1914Various
Science
The Delinquent, Vol. IV, No. 6, June, 1914
Various
Prisons -- Periodicals
Per cent.
Considerably above ordinary in ability 3
Ordinary or fair in ability 55
Poor in ability 9
Mentally dull, but suffering from defective physical
conditions, or disease, or bad habits, which may be the
cause of the dullness 8
Sub-normal mentally, but not strictly feebleminded 8
Feebleminded (moron grade) 9
Feebleminded (imbecile grade) 1
Psychoses, ranging from well marked cases of insanity to
temporary, but well-marked mental aberrations 7
I have found in various parts of the country considerable doubt
expressed in regard to various statements which have been made of
the proportions of the feebleminded which probably would be found
by studying juvenile offenders. Teachers, judges, and probation
officers have scouted the idea that there was upwards of 25 per cent.
feebleminded among the children which come before a Juvenile court. Our
own long investigation would certainly show otherwise. But of course we
have never seen all of the thousands of children which come into the
Chicago court yearly, so we have never been able to definitely answer
the question of just what proportion is mentally defective.
This year I have asked the assistant director of the Institute, Miss
Bronner, to undertake at regular periods cross-section studies of the
population temporarily held in the Detention Home. These probably would
average lower than if one could see every case which was brought into
court, for frequently the most normal children who have been engaged
in a single offense are not brought into the Home. The results which
she is obtaining I shall merely hint at, but they serve to show that
the psychological study of delinquency involves very much more than the
discrimination of the feebleminded.
Any one who observed the considerable proportion of 7th and 8th grade
and high school girls and boys who become severely delinquent will not
be surprised at our findings. At least 91 per cent. of the girls and 84
per cent. of the boys have been found so far to group normal mentally,
if we take the 12 year old tests of Binet as a standard. Now, as a
matter of fact, I am not at all inclined without further investigation
to denominate anyone as mentally defective who can not pass the 12
year test, because of the obvious weakness of these particular five
tests for judging such an important point. But still we have been
willing to place this criticism for the moment aside. There are several
details of this given study which might be interesting to discuss, but
this will be done elsewhere.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account