The doctor looks at biography : $b Psychological studies of life and lettersCollins, Joseph
History
The doctor looks at biography : $b Psychological studies of life and letters
Collins, Joseph
Autobiography; Biography as a literary form; Literature, Modern -- 20th century -- History and criticism
Mrs. Gaskell’s _Life of Charlotte Brontë_, after many vicissitudes,
has taken a place among the great biographies. Soon after its
publication about seventy years ago, it was alleged by many to be
unsound, untruthful, unjust, but time has shown it to be a remarkably
accurate picture of a humourless genius who was sensitive, shy and
temperamental, and whose statements were sometimes founded in fancy
rather than in fact.
Biography-writing has been influenced, as novel-writing has been, by
the researches and discoveries of modern psychology, particularly by
the teachings of Freud, and to a lesser extent of the behaviourists.
The most prominent representative of this “new” kind of biography
is Gamaliel Bradford. He is not, however, a Freudian, but a sane,
temperate, laboriously trained writer who has a profound regard for
facts, great industry in unearthing them, and much skill in serving
them daintily and appetisingly, seasoned with fancy, to the reading
public. Mr. Harvey O’Higgins has swallowed the doctrines of the
Viennese mystic, bait, line and sinker, and in _The American Mind
in Action_ he has attempted to show how well he has digested and
assimilated them. A journalist by training, he has mastered the
Freudian jargon, and he writes it with the same ease that James Joyce
writes of the subconscious distillation and conscious crystallisation
of Mr. and Mrs. Bloom. He is the Técla of biographers, but he offers
his goods to the trade as genuine. They do not deceive experts. He
is attempting to do for biographies what Dr. George M. Gould did a
few years ago in his biographical clinics. Only he substituted the
Œdipus-complex for Eye Strain.
Œdipus Redivivus will have a longer day in court than Eye Strain had
and more spectators, and there is a salaciousness about the testimony
elicited that the elicitors and the audience like, but the verdict in
both cases will be similar.
A form of biography that is apparently finding great favour is
represented by such books as _The Divine Lady_, _Ariel_, _The Portrait
of Zélide_, _The Nightingale_, _Glorious Apollo_. It is an elaboration
of the variety popularised by Mr. Gamaliel Bradford which he calls
psychographs. These are psychographs and somagraphs flavoured with
time-denatured scandal. They are easy reading, mildly instructive,
and moderately diverting. They are a good substitute for fiction and
a fairly acceptable one for history, and they are infinitely to be
preferred to biographic fiction such as _He Was a Man_, the life of
Jack London, by Rose Wilder Lane.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account