(_a_) For the natural meaning, take the example, “Some engines can drag a train at a mile a minute for a long distance.” [1] This does not _mean_ a certain number of engines, though of course they _are_ a certain number. It {117} means certain engines of a particular make, not specified in the Judgment. The Judgment is Categorical, because the undefined reservation implies a reference to something unanalysed, but merely touched or presented in experience. If it was a mere idea it would have to be clear; and if the full description or definition were inserted, the Judgment would cease to affirm the existence of the engines in question. _And the Judgment itself challenges this completion._ [1] To be accurate, the Judgment would demand the insertion of precise details about train, distance, and other matters. But this illustrates the point of the text, because the assignment of such details would naturally extend to the Subject, and then the “Some” would be displaced. _A narrower meaning_ (_b_) A more artificial meaning is to take the Judgment as not formed by imperfect description, but by imperfect enumeration (understanding it almost wholly in denotation). “Some Conservatives are in favour of women’s suffrage.” This means or may mean that we have counted a certain number, large or small, who are so, and we may or may not know about the others. _Thus understood, the Judgment challenges complete enumeration_; it contains of course the elements of a fraction--half, most, nine-tenths of, and so on. This again is Categorical; not merely because it implies counting, but because it implies counting units separately given to experience. The Particular Judgment does not include our Impersonal and Demonstrative Judgments; they are not classed in the common text-books. But as referring to perception they too are categorical and assert facts, whether they have ideas to help out the perceptive reference or not. And there is no reason against including them under the Particular Judgment. The assertion, “This engine can drag a train a mile a minute,” is much the same kind of Judgment as, “Some engines can, etc.” Either of these would be false {118} if no such engines existed. _These Judgments are of the essence of perception_. They have the connection of content and the undefined complex of presentation struggling together in them. They assert fact. _Singular Judgment_