The essentials of mysticism, and other essaysUnderhill, Evelyn
Religion
The essentials of mysticism, and other essays
Underhill, Evelyn
Mysticism
So much we have said of will. What place have we left for the operation
of feeling in prayer? It is not easy to disentangle will and feeling;
for in all intense will there is a strong element of emotion—every
volitional act has somewhere at the back of it a desire—and in all great
and energizing passions there is a pronounced volitional element. The
“synthesis of love and will” is no mere fancy of the psychologist. It is
a compound hard to break down in practice. But I think we can say
generally that the business of feeling is to inflame the will, to give
it intention, gladness, and vividness; to convert it from a dull
determination into an eager, impassioned desire. It links up thought
with action; effects, in psychological language, the movement of the
prayerful self from a mere state of cognition to a state of conation;
converts the soul from attention to the Transcendent to first-hand
adventure within it. “All thy life now behoveth altogether to stand in
desire,” says the author of the _Cloud of Unknowing_ to the disciple who
has accepted the principle of prayer; and here he is declaring a
psychological necessity rather than a religious platitude, for all
successful action has its origin in emotion of some kind. Though we
choose to imagine that “pure reason” directs our conduct, in the last
resort we always do a thing because of the feeling that we have about
it. Not necessarily because we like doing it; but because instinctive
feeling of some sort—selfish or unselfish, personal, social,
conventional, sacrificial; the disturbing emotion called the sense of
duty, or the glorious emotion called the passion of love—is urging us to
it. Instinctive emotions, more or less sublimated; Love, Hatred,
Ambition, Fear, Anger, Hunger, Patriotism, Self-interest; these are the
true names of our reasons for doing things.
If this be true of our reactions to the physical world, it is none the
less true of our intercourse with the spiritual world. The will is moved
to seek that intercourse by emotion, by feeling; never by a merely
intellectual conviction. In the vigour and totality with which the
heroes of religion give themselves to spiritual interests, and in the
powers which they develop, we see the marks of instinctive feeling
operating upon the highest levels. By “a leash of longing,” says the
_Cloud of Unknowing_ again, man is led to be the servant of God; not by
the faultless deductions of dialectic, but by the mysterious logic of
the heart. He is moved most often, perhaps, by an innate unformulated
craving for perfection, or by the complementary loathing of
imperfection—a love of God, or a hatred of self—by the longing for
peace, the miserable sensations of disillusion, of sin, and of unrest,
the heart’s deep conviction that it needs a changeless object for its
love. Or, if by none of these, then by some other emotional stimulus.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account