Some philosophers have reason to suppose that mind can act directly on
mind without intervening mechanism,--and sometimes that has been
spoken of as genuine action at a distance; but no proper conception or
physical model can be made of such a process, nor is it clear that
"space" and "distance" have any particular meaning in the region of
psychology. The links between mind and mind may be something quite
other than physical proximity; and in denying action at a distance
across empty space I am not denying telepathy or other activities of a
non-physical kind. For although brain disturbance is certainly
physical, and is an essential concomitant of mental action whether of
the sending or receiving variety, yet we know from the case of heat
that a material movement can be excited in one place at the expense of
corresponding movement in another, without any similar kind of
transmission or material connexion between the two places: the thing
that travels across vacuum is not heat.
In all cases where physical motion is involved, however, I would have
a medium sought for. It may not be matter, but it must be something;
there must be a connecting link of some kind, or the transference
cannot occur. There can be no attraction across really empty space.
And even when a material link exists, so that the connexion is
obvious, the explanation is not complete; for when the mechanism of
attraction is understood, it will be found that a body really only
moves because it is pushed by something from behind. The essential
force in nature is the _vis a tergo_. So when we have found the
"traces," or discovered the connecting thread, we still run up against
the word "cohesion"; and we ought to be exercised in our minds as to
its ultimate meaning. Why the whole of a rod should follow, when one
end is pulled, is a matter requiring explanation; and the only
explanation that can be given involves, in some form or other, a
continuous medium connecting the discrete and separated particles or
atoms of matter.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account