The Ethics of Diet: A Catena of Authorities Deprecatory of the Practice of Flesh EatingWilliams, Howard
Philosophy
The Ethics of Diet: A Catena of Authorities Deprecatory of the Practice of Flesh Eating
Williams, Howard
Diet; Vegetarianism
It is generally acknowledged to be one of the best books on the
subject. Haller pronounced it to be “the best of all the works bearing
upon the health of sedentary persons and invalids.” It went through
several editions in the space of two years, and in 1726 was enlarged by
the author and translated by his friend and pupil John Robertson M.A.
into Latin, and three or four editions were quickly exhausted in France
and Germany. In this book, while reducing flesh-meat to a _minimum_,
and insisting upon the necessity of abstinence from grosser food and of
the use of vegetables only, at the morning and evening meals, he had
not advanced as yet so far as to preach the truth in its entirety. He
arrived at it only by slow and gradual conviction. Expatiating on the
follies and miseries of _bon-vivantism_, he proceeds to affirm that--
“All those who have lived long, and without much pain, have lived
abstemiously, poor, and meagre. Cornaro prolonged his life and
preserved his senses by almost starving in his latter days; and
some others have done the like. They have, indeed, thereby, in some
measure, weakened their natural strength and qualified the fire
and flux of their spirits, but they have preserved their senses,
weakened their pains, prolonged their days, and procured themselves
a gentle and quiet passage into another state.... All the rest
will be insufficient without this [a frugal diet]; and this alone,
without these [medicines, &c.], will suffice to carry on life as
long as by its natural flame it was made to last, and will make the
passage easy and calm, as a taper goes out for want of fuel.”
While the _Essay of Health_ added greatly to his reputation with all
thinking people, it also exposed him (as was to be expected) to a storm
of small wit, ridicule, and misrepresentation:--
“Some good-natured and ingenious retainers to the Profession,” he
tells us, “on the publication of my book on _Long Life and Health_,
proclaimed everywhere that I was turned mere enthusiast, advised
people to turn monks, to run into deserts, and to live on roots,
herbs, and wild fruits! in fine, that I was, at bottom, a mere
leveller, and for destroying order, ranks, and property, everyone’s
but my own. But that sneer had its day, and vanished into smoke.
Others swore that I had eaten my book, recanted my _doctrine_ and
_system_ (as they were pleased to term it), and was returned again
to the devil, the world, and the flesh. This joke I have also
stood. I have been slain again and again, both in prose and verse;
but, I thank God, I am still alive and well.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account