The Ethics of Diet: A Catena of Authorities Deprecatory of the Practice of Flesh EatingWilliams, Howard
Philosophy
The Ethics of Diet: A Catena of Authorities Deprecatory of the Practice of Flesh Eating
Williams, Howard
Diet; Vegetarianism
“To such a degree do we make luxuries of bloodshed, that we call
flesh ‘a delicacy,’ and forthwith require delicate sauces [ὄψων]
for this same flesh-meat, and mix together oil and wine and honey
and pickle and vinegar with all the spices of Syria and Arabia--for
all the world as though we were embalming a human corpse. After all
these heterogeneous matters have been mixed and dissolved and, in
a manner, corrupted, it is for the stomach, forsooth, to masticate
and assimilate them--if it can. And though this may be, for the
time, accomplished, the natural sequence is a variety of diseases,
produced by imperfect digestion and repletion.[48]
“Diogenes (the Cynic) had the courage, on one occasion, to swallow
a _polypus_ without any cooking preparation, to dispense with the
time and trouble expended in the kitchen. In the presence of a
numerous concourse of priests and others, unwrapping the morsel
from his tattered cloak, and putting it to his lips, ‘For your
sakes,’ cried he, ‘I perform this extravagant action and incur this
danger.’ A self-sacrifice truly meritorious! Not like Pelopidas,
for the freedom of Thebes, or like Harmodius and Aristogeiton,
on behalf of the citizens of Athens, did the philosopher submit
to this hazardous experiments; for _he_ acted thus that he might
_unbarbarise_, if possible, the life of human kind.
“Flesh-eating is not unnatural to our physical constitution only.
The mind and intellect are made gross by gorging and repletion;
for flesh-meat and wine may possibly tend to give robustness
to the body, but it gives only feebleness to the mind. Not to
incur the resentment of the prize-fighters [the _athletes_], I
will avail myself of examples nearer home. The wits of Athens,
it is well known, bestow on us Bœotians the epithets ‘gross,’
‘dull-brained,’ and ‘stupid,’ chiefly on account of our gross
feeding. We are even called ‘hogs.’ Menander nicknames us the
‘jaw-people’ [οἱ γνάθους ἔχοντες]. Pindar has it that ‘mind is a
very secondary consideration with them.’ ‘A fine understanding of
clouded brilliancy’ is the ironical phrase of Herakleitus....
“Besides and beyond all these reasons, does it not seem admirable
to foster habits of philanthropy? Who that is so kindly and gently
disposed towards beings of another species would ever be inclined
to do injury to his own kind? I remember in conversation hearing,
as a saying of Xenokrates, that the Athenians imposed a penalty
upon a man for flaying a sheep alive, and he who tortures a living
being is little worse (it seems to me) than he who needlessly
deprives of life and murders outright. We have, it appears, clearer
perceptions of what is contrary to propriety and custom than of
what is contrary to nature....
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account