The Ethics of Medical Homicide and MutilationO'Malley, Austin
Religion
The Ethics of Medical Homicide and Mutilation
O'Malley, Austin
Medical ethics
Again, St. Augustine said:[19] "I do not know how the soul came into
my body; he knows who gave it, whether he drew it [_traxerit_] from
my father, or created it new as in the first man." In the _Book of
Retractions_,[20] speaking of the articles he had written against the
Academicians before he was a bishop, he says: "As to the origin of
the soul, how it is set in the body--whether it is from that one man
who first was created ... or, as in his case, is made particularly
for each particular individual, I did not then know, and I do not
know now." St. Gregory the Great also said he could not tell whether
the human soul descends from Adam or is given particularly to each
man.
[19] _De Anima et ejus Origine_, i, xv.
[20] I, cap. i, n. 3.
St. Gregory of Nyssa, however, who died about 385, thirty years
before St. Augustine wrote the letter to St. Jerome, held that the
soul is infused into the body at the moment of conception, and he
argues with absolute precision for his opinion.[21] St. Maximus the
Theologian, who was martyred in 662, inveighs[22] against the notion
that the soul is vegetative at first, then sensitive, and finally
intellectual, and he thinks the assertion of Aristotle that the fetus
is not animated before the fortieth day is altogether untrue.
[21] Migne, _Patrologia Graeca_, vols. xliv and xlvi.
[22] Migne, _Ibid._, vol. xci, col. 1335.
St. Anselm, who died in 1109, very dogmatically denied that the fetus
is animated at conception,[23] and after his time the doctrine of
Aristotle, which is commonly called the Thomistic opinion, became
almost general. Vincent of Beauvais, however, a contemporary of St.
Thomas, opposed the Thomistic doctrine. Albertus Magnus[24] had the
same opinion as St. Thomas, and probably taught it to St. Thomas. In
the middle ages all held that each soul is directly created by God,
and is infused into the embryo, not at the instant of conception,
but when the embryo is sufficiently formed to receive it, which, as
Aristotle said, happens at about the fortieth day in males and the
eightieth day in females. The Thomists maintained the succession of
the three souls; many others opposed this particular opinion.
[23] _De Conceptione Virginis_, cap. xii.
[24] _Summa, De Homine_, q. xvi, art. 3.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account