Three special instances or classes of instances, according to our
author's account, may be used as illustrations of this general type of
hypotheses. They are: (1) The hypothesis of the existence of continuous
extensive _quanta_ in nature; (2) The principles of geometry; (3) The
principles of mechanics and of the general theory of energy. In case of
each of these special types of hypotheses we are at first disposed,
apart from reflection, to say that we _find_ the world to be thus or
thus, so that, for instance, we can confirm the thesis according to
which nature contains continuous magnitudes; or can prove or disprove
the physical truth of the postulates of Euclidean geometry; or can
confirm by definite experience the objective validity of the principles
of mechanics. A closer examination reveals, according to our author, the
incorrectness of all such opinions. Hypotheses of these various special
types are needed; and their usefulness can be empirically shown. They
are in touch with experience; and that they are not merely arbitrary
conventions is also verifiable. They are not _a priori_ necessities; and
we can easily conceive intelligent beings whose experience could be best
interpreted without using these hypotheses. Yet these hypotheses are
_not_ subject to direct confirmation or refutation by experience. They
stand then in sharp contrast to the scientific hypotheses of the other,
and more frequently recognized, type, _i. e._, to the hypotheses which
can be tested by a definite appeal to experience. To these other
hypotheses our author attaches, of course, great importance. His
treatment of them is full of a living appreciation of the significance
of empirical investigation. But the central problem of the logic of
science thus becomes the problem of the relation between the two
fundamentally distinct types of hypotheses, _i. e._, between those which
can not be verified or refuted through experience, and those which can
be empirically tested.
IV
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account