Free thought; Modernism (Christian theology) -- Catholic Church; Religion and science; Teaching, Freedom of
Therefore, so it is said, we have now broken definitely with the “dogmatic
method of reasoning” of the belief in revelation, and of scholastic
philosophy which adhered to absolute truth. They are replaced by the
historical-genetical reasoning of the _saeculum historicum_ which “has
discarded absolute truth: there are only relative, no eternal truths”
(_Paulsen_, Immanuel Kant, 1898, 389). We are further assured that “this
treatment of the history of thought prevails in the scientific world; the
Catholic Church alone has not adopted it. She still clings to dogmatic
reasoning, and that is natural to her; she is sure that she is in
possession of the absolute truth” (Idem, Philosophia militans, 2d ed.,
1901, 5). Outside of this Church every period of time is free to construct
its own theories, which will eventually go with it as they came with it.
We meet this relative truth, and all the indefinable hazy notions
identified with it, _in all spheres_.
The modern history of philosophy and religion concedes to every
system and religion the right to their historic position: they are
necessary phases of evolution. The notion of immutable problems
and truths by which any system of thought would have to be
measured has been lost. “The appearance and rejection of a
system,” says _J. E. Erdmann_, “is a necessity of world-history.
The former was demanded by the character of the time which the
system reflected, the latter again is demanded by the fact that
the time has changed” (Grundriss der Geschichte der Philosophie,
3rd, I, 1878, 4). And Professor _Eucken_ says: “Despite all its
advantages, such a view and construction of life is not a definite
truth, it remains an attempt, a problem that always causes new
discord among minds” (Grundlinien einer neuen Lebensanschauung,
1907, 2). “Thus, if according to _Hegel_ the coming into being
constitutes the truth of being, the ideals and aims also must
share in the mobility, and truth becomes a child of the times
(_veritas temporis filia_). That apparently subjects life to a
full-blown relativism, but such a relativism has lost all its
terror by the deterioration of the older method of reasoning. For
agreement with existing truth is no longer its chief object.”
(Geistige Stroemungen der Gegenwart, 1904, p. 197). The new theory
of knowledge assures us quite generally: “It is a vain attempt to
single out certain lasting primitive forms of consciousness,
acknowledged constant elements of the mind, to retain them. Every
‘a-priori’ principle which is thus maintained as an unalienable
dowry of thought, as a necessary result of its psychological and
physiological ‘disposition,’ will prove an obstacle of which the
progress of science will steer clear sooner or later” (_E.
Cassirer_, Das Erkenntnissproblem in der Philosophie und
Wissenschaft der neueren Zeit, 1906, 6).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account