“The modern city,” says Superintendent Wirt, “is largely the result of
the application of the principle of the common use of public facilities
that we need for our personal use only part of the time. We are willing
that other people use public services when we cannot use them. How many
street-cars and what sort of service could we afford if each citizen had
to have his own private street-car seat for his own exclusive use?” Yet
the educational ideal in school management generally remains what is set
forth in the report of the 1913 Part-Time Committee of the New York
public schools,—“Every pupil is entitled to an individual seat and desk.
The teacher is entitled to the exclusive possession of a classroom....”
In the light of the Gary plan this ideal is absurd. It means, as has
been discovered in the New York experience, that school facilities can
never be made to catch up to school population. And it is absurd because
it assumes that all persons in school want to do the same thing at the
same time. But all “modern public conveniences are made possible only by
their common use and the fact that we do not want to use the same public
conveniences at the same moment. We are willing to have some one else
use our public library, look at our pictures in our public museum, walk
in our public park, sleep in our Pullman berth or in our hotel bedroom,
or travel in our steamboat when we are otherwise engaged.” It proves to
be as financially prohibitive to attempt to provide an individual desk
and seat for every school-child as it is to provide an individual seat
for every citizen who may sit in the park. “The great masses of children
in our city schools can never have ample play spaces, suitable
auditoriums, gymnasiums and swimming-pools, workshops, libraries,
museums, or even ordinary schoolrooms for study and recitation, if all
children at the same time must be using each of these facilities
separately.” The more people use these public services, the cheaper they
become for each one of us. And the more evenly the public use is
distributed, the more valuable becomes the service to each one of us.
“Increasing the number of persons using any public facility either under
public or private ownership betters the service for all, provided the
load can be uniformly distributed during operating hours. The problem
with a public lighting or transportation service is to eliminate
‘peak-loads’ as far as possible.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account