The Goose-step: A Study of American EducationSinclair, Upton
History
The Goose-step: A Study of American Education
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States; Universities and colleges -- United States
The University of Wisconsin has the reputation of being the most liberal
institution of higher education in the United States, and on the whole I
think the reputation is deserved. I have shown what a struggle it took
to introduce one little impulse of new thinking into the place; and you
must realize that every mite of freedom has been won by the same
struggle, and the maintaining of it depends upon somebody’s willingness
to be disagreeable. I talked with one professor, who is known throughout
the United States as a writer and lecturer, not a Socialist, but a
tireless advocate of social justice. This man has won, and he holds
grimly the right to have his own say and his own way. He assigns to his
graduate students “The Brass Check” as required reading, and as their
thesis they make a study of some capitalist newspaper in its handling of
half a dozen crucial public issues, such as the steel strike and Mexican
intervention.
The rub comes when the professor goes outside and lectures to city clubs
and chambers of commerce, and gets into the newspapers in favor of the
recognition of Soviet Russia. Then all the reactionaries in the state
clamor for his scalp. He said to me: “They say a fox learns to enjoy
being chased, and in the same way I have had to learn to enjoy
outmatching my enemies. I feel that I am being stalked by a band of
thugs; I have to set out deliberately and consciously to build up my
prestige throughout the state, to keep myself in the public mind, so
that my enemies won’t dare go beyond abusing me. Manifestly, that means
that academic freedom is only for the man who has a tough skin and can
be happy in a fight. The young man, also the weak man, is helpless; if
he tries to tell the truth about anything, he’ll have to go out and
write life insurance for a living.”
Such is the judgment, after nearly two decades’ experience, of one of
America’s freest college professors, in America’s freest university.
That many men should fail in such a test is inevitable. There is another
professor in the university, an elderly man, who began his career as a
Socialist of the academic type; he is the author of standard books on
Socialism, and all through the years when he made his reputation he
recognized the unearned increment of land as a grave form of social
injustice. He has now changed his views, and has become the tamest of
conservatives, a pitiable figure. It happened recently that a friend of
mine was in his office, and discovered an economic basis for this
transformation. Some one wanted to buy some lots from the old professor;
and the price was two thousand dollars each, he said. He listened to
some protest of the would-be purchaser; then he said: “I know; the price
was eighteen hundred a couple of weeks ago, but it has now gone up.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account