The Goose-step: A Study of American Education — John Shaqi
The Goose-step: A Study of American EducationSinclair, Upton
History
The Goose-step: A Study of American Education
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States; Universities and colleges -- United States
He is; and so he was driven from the University of Automobiles. His
story was told to me by some of his former students, who ask me not to
use his name; he has another job, and might very easily lose that. So
let us call him Smithfield. He began teaching at Ann Arbor fifteen years
ago, starting in on rhetoric. Naturally, the way to make rhetoric
interesting is to see how it is used by live writers; so Smithfield and
his classes would read H. G. Wells, and the plays and prefaces of
Bernard Shaw, and the essays of John Stuart Mill. He would set his
classes interesting stunts to do; a passage from Wells to write over in
the style of Milton, or one of Shakespeare in the manner of Carlyle. His
classes grew, and when he turned them over to others they fell off. The
head of the department brought him three boys, sons of the interlocking
directorate, who could not pass; Smithfield taught them, and they
passed. “It’s a marvel,” said the professor; “I don’t see how you do
it.”
But parents began to complain. Their children were coming home with
different ideas; they were learning real things about modern life,
instead of the pretenses the parents were used to! A nephew of Mr. Henry
Leland, of Lincoln Motors, brought to Mr. Bulkley, the banker, at that
time a regent, the dreadful story that Smithfield was a Socialist; so
the president of the university summoned him in haste: “My dear
Smithfield,” said he, “can’t you see that if you were to divide
everything up, it would not be many years before the more able people
had got possession of everything again?” Such was the mentality of the
aged native product; and he was backed by Mr. Beal, the resident regent,
owner of banks and saloon real estate. The boys had to come to this
latter to ask for the use of a hall for a lecture by some unorthodox
person, and they would regularly be asked this question about dividing
up!
Matters got so serious, with complaints of rich parents, that there was
a formal investigation by a committee. Thirty students were corralled
and questioned by five members of the faculty. “Have you ever read a
Socialist book? Have you ever been to a Socialist lecture? Where did you
get these ideas? Were you taught Socialism by Professor Smithfield?” One
and all, the boys testified that Smithfield had never taught them
Socialism; he had taught them to think. He had been tireless in
impressing upon them that they should learn to hold their minds in
suspense, and to judge for themselves; they should test new ideas, and
accept what they found convincing to their reason. As a result of this
investigation, one of the deans informed Smithfield that he had been
suspended by the regents, but this statement turned out not to be
true—not yet!
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account