The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs) — John Shaqi
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
_Second: They bring their political passions into their activities as
‘clerks’._
The ‘clerks’ have not been content simply to adopt political passions,
if by this one means that they have made a place for these passions
side by side with the activities they are bound to carry on as
‘clerks’. They have introduced these passions into those activities.
They permit, they desire them to be mingled with their work as artists,
as men of learning, as philosophers, to colour the essence of their
work and to mark all its productions. And indeed never were there so
many political works among those which ought to be the mirror of the
disinterested intelligence.
You may refuse to be surprised by this in the case of poetry. We must
not ask the poets to separate their works from their passions. The
latter are the substance of the former, and the only question to ask
is whether they write poems to express their passions or whether they
hunt for passions in order to write poems. In either case one does
not see why they should exclude national passion or the spirit of
party from their vibrant material. Our political poets, who are not
numerous however, have only followed the example of Virgil, Claudian,
Lucan, Dante, d’Aubigné, Ronsard, and Hugo. Yet we cannot deny that
political passion, as it is expressed by Claudel or d’Annunzio, a
conscious and organized passion _lacking all simplicity_, coldly
scornful of its adversary, a passion which in the second of these
poets displays itself as so precisely political, so cunningly adapted
to the profound cupidity of his compatriots and the exact point of
weakness in the foreigner--we cannot deny, I say, that this political
passion is something different from the eloquent generalities of the
‘Tragiques of the Année Terrible.’ A work like _La Nave_, with its
national plan as exact and practical as that of a Bismarck, wherein
the lyric gift is used to extol this practical character, seems to me
something new in the history of poetry, even of political poetry. The
result of this new departure on the minds of laymen may be judged by
the present state of mind of the Italian people.[48] But in our day
the most remarkable example of the poets’ applying their art to the
service of political passions is that literary form which may be called
‘lyrical philosophy’, the most brilliant symbol of which is the work of
Barrès. It begins by taking as its centres of vibration certain truly
philosophical states of mind (such as pantheism, a loftily sceptical
intellectualism) and then entirely devotes itself to serving racial
passion and national feeling. Here the action of the lyric spirit is
doubled by the prestige of the spirit of abstract thought (Barrès
admirably caught the appearance of that spirit--he stole the tool, a
philosopher has said of him), and in France as elsewhere the ‘clerks’
have thereby stimulated political passions among the laymen, at least
in that very important section of them who read and believe they think.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account