The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
The susceptibility developed by national sentiment as it has become
popular makes the possibility of wars far greater to-day than in the
past. Obviously, with the peoples and with the aptitude of these new
‘sovereigns’ to rise up in a rage as soon as they think they are
insulted, peace runs an additional danger which did not exist when it
depended only upon Kings and their Ministers, who were far more purely
practical persons, fully self-controlled, and quite willing to put up
with insults when they did not think themselves the stronger party.[11]
And, in fact, how many times during the last hundred years has the
world almost flamed up in war solely because some nation thought its
honour had been wounded?[12] To this must be added the fact that this
national susceptibility provides the leaders of nations with a new and
most effective method of starting the wars they need, whether it is
employed at home or abroad. They have not failed to see this, which
is amply proved by the example of Bismarck and the means by which he
provoked war with Austria and with France. From this point of view
it seems to me quite correct to say with the French monarchists that
‘democracy is war’, provided that by democracy is meant the attainment
of national susceptibility by the masses, and provided that it is
recognized that no change in the system of government would destroy
this phenomenon.[13]
Another considerable deepening of national passions comes from the fact
that the nations are now conscious of themselves not only as regards
their material existence, their military power, their territorial
possessions, and their economic wealth, but as regards their _moral_
existence. With a hitherto unknown consciousness (prodigiously fanned
by authors) every nation now hugs itself and sets itself up against all
other nations as superior in language, art, literature, philosophy,
civilization, ‘culture’. Patriotism to-day is the assertion of one
form of mind against other forms of mind.[14] We know how much this
passion increases its inner strength in this way and that the wars
it determines are fiercer than those waged by the Kings, who merely
desired the same piece of territory. The prophecy of the old Saxon bard
is completely fulfilled: ‘In those days countries will be something
they have not yet become--they will be persons. They will feel hatred,
and these hatreds will cause wars more terrible than any that have yet
been seen.’[15]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account