Jewish philosophy -- Early works to 1800; Judaism -- Works to 1900; Philosophy, Medieval -- Early works to 1800
II. Translations. a. Hebrew.—As soon as European Jews heard of the
existence of this work, they procured its translation into Hebrew. Two
scholars, independently of each other, undertook the task: Samuel Ibn
Tibbon and Jehudah al-Ḥarizi. There is, besides, in the Moreh ha-moreh
of Shemṭob Palquera an original translation of some portions of the
Moreh. In the Sifte yeshenim (No. 112) a rhymed translation of the
Dalalat by Rabbi Mattityahu Kartin is mentioned. Ibn Tibbon’s version
is very accurate; he sacrificed elegance of style to the desire of
conscientiously reproducing the author’s work, and did not even neglect
a particle, however unimportant it may appear. Ibn Tibbon went in his
anxiety to retain peculiarities of the original so far as to imitate
its ambiguities, e.g., meẓiut (I. lviii.) is treated as a masculine
noun, only in order to leave it doubtful whether a pronoun which
follows agrees with meẓiut, “existence,” or with nimẓa, “existing
being,” both occurring in the same sentence (Br. Mus. MS. Harl. 7586,
marg. note by Ibn Tibbon). When he met with passages that offered any
difficulty he consulted Maimonides. Ḥarizi, on the other hand, was less
conscientious about words and particles, but wrote in a superior style.
Vox populi, however, decided in favour of the version of Ibn Tibbon,
the rival of which became almost forgotten. Also Abraham, the son of
Moses Maimonides, in Milḥamoth ha-shem, describes Ḥarizi’s version as
being inaccurate. Most of the modern translations were made from Ibn
Tibbon’s version. There are, therefore, MSS. of this version almost in
every library containing collections of Hebrew books and MSS. It has
the title Moreh-nebuchim. The British Museum has the following eight
copies of Ibn Tibbon’s version:—
Harl. 7586 A. This codex was written in the year 1284, for Rabbi
Shabbatai ben Rabbi Mattityahu. In the year 1340 it came into the
possession of Jacob b. Shelomoh; his son Menaḥem sold it in the year
1378 to R. Mattityahu, son of R. Shabbatai, for fifty gold florins. It
was again sold in the year 1461 by Yeḥiel ben Joab. There is this
peculiarity in the writing, that long words at the end of a line are
divided, and written half on the one line, half on the next; in words
which are vocalized, pataḥ is frequently found for ḳameẓ. There are
numerous various readings in the margin. The text is preceded by a
poem, written by Joseph Ibn Aknin, pupil of Maimonides, in praise of
his master, and beginning Adon yiẓro. This poem is attributed to R.
Yehudah ha-Levi (Luzzatto, in his Divan, Betulat-bat-Yehudah, p. 104).
At the end the copyist adds an epigram, the translation of which is as
follows:—
“The Moreh is finished—Praise to Him who formed and created
everything—written for the instruction and benefit of the few whom the
Lord calleth. Those who oppose the Moreh ought to be put to death; but
those who study and understand it deserve that Divine Glory rest upon
them, and inspire them with a spirit from above.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account