The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
The conditions of the life of the present-day, the current habits of
thought, the social relationships of men, the economic situation of the
country, the welfare of family and Church, and the relations of those
institutions and groups that make their conflicting claims upon the
loyalty and cover so much of the activity of individuals, are rich with
problems and anomalies, and situations and combinations of circumstance
which are peculiar to the age, and are the source of most of the issues
of the novel of the present-day. The entanglement of the individuals in
these conditions produces problems of experience that are peculiarly
modern. In the same way every set of circumstances produces its special
set of human issues, every age has its own life-problems; and the novel
of an age of monasticism will range through a different scheme of
problems from that of an age of divorce-law activity, and the world of
the Industrial Movement will show life dominated by issues different
from those of the age of Chivalry. The twentieth century differs from
the twelfth not merely in its language, its dress, its implements
and armour, but in its whole experience of life. It is not merely in
the suits and trappings that one age contrasts with another; and for
this reason the historical novel is justified, as something more than
picturesque scene-painting, for it treats of other ages’ experiments
in living, and depicts human nature breaking in upon a different
set of experiences, a different range of problems. When Scott in the
Introductions to _Ivanhoe_ and to _The Monastery_ summarises a state
of society therefore, and assumes a given set of human relationships
as the basis of a novel, he is carrying with these things the whole
range of experiences and issues that are involved in them and that
are peculiar to them, and his purpose is to turn these into story as
a present-day novelist turns the social conditions of the twentieth
century into fiction.
History, then, is not merely a taskmaster to the novelist. Too often
the historical novelist has been spoken of as being hampered by history
and tied down by chronological tables. He has been regarded as a
novelist working under limitations and with one hand tied, history
restricting his imagination, and setting him a boundary. But all that
has just been said implies that history is not merely the chain that
ties the novelist down; rather it is the wing that helps him to soar
into a new range of problems and experiences. It is his inspiration,
and not simply a tie. When Scott in his Introductions gave himself
a basis for his novels it is true that he was accepting certain
limitations and agreeing to work within a given set of facts, just as
an Arctic explorer agrees to accept the hardships of cold weather; but
at the same time he was opening up to himself a different world and a
life that rested on a different basis and that so provided him with a
host of fresh story-issues.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account