The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
If the historical novelist regards his duty as being to avoid
anachronisms, history will seem to him a chain. The different condition
of things existing in the period of which he writes will be a source
of labour to him, and a pitfall. But to the true historical novelist
they are a glory, they are the whole point of his work, and what was a
weakness becomes a strength. If a writer wishes to “work up” a period
in order to set a story in it, he will feel history a fetter and every
unexpected fact may hamper the story he intended to tell. But if he
has steeped his mind in some past age, and has lived in that age,
turning it over and over in his imagination, realising the conditions
of affairs and the relationships of men and pondering over the
implications of these and so recasting the life of the age for himself,
then that particular age and those special conditions will suggest
their own story, and the historical peculiarities of that age will give
point to his novel and will become a power. There is all the difference
in the world between a man who has a story to tell and wishes to set
it in a past age and to adjust it to the demands of history, and the
man who has the past in his head and allows it to come forth in story.
There is an immense gulf between the man who works up a period in
history in order to tell his story without anachronisms, and a man
whose stories come from a mind steeped in the past. In the one case
history has to be laboriously gathered up around the story, and it is a
burden; in the other case the history is there to begin with, and the
story grows out of the history. In the true historical novel the writer
has learned to feel at home in the age with which he is dealing. Such
a novel comes out of a world of the Past that exists in the writer’s
mind. The history that it embodies will be true or inaccurate according
as the man has throughout his life built up that world in his mind on
true foundations, but in any case that history will come spontaneously;
and here the historical novelist is not a novelist working under
limitations, but one who has captured new fields of experience and of
circumstance and has conquered a new world for his art.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account