The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
It has been noticed that the ostensible theme of _The Cloister and the
Hearth_ is an instance of a human problem that came out in a particular
form in mediaeval life, but exists in some form in every society.
The problem is one of loyalties that cut across each other and pull
different ways. A modern novelist would be likely to treat this as a
study in human experience and would analyse the disruption it would
cause in the individual soul. Reade, however, is a Victorian, who lived
before the psychological novel had become the fashion, and he does the
Victorian thing; instead of treating this problem as the real theme of
his novel, he pushes it on one side, and makes it simply the excuse for
sending his hero on a journey, so that his story becomes very largely a
story of travel.
The simplest kind of novel is the novel of this kind, which gives a
string of happenings that befell the hero in his wandering through the
world. It is not the working-out of a plot, or the following-up of a
situation. It does not turn upon a definite set of relations which
provide a problem for the novelist to solve, a knot for him to untie;
it does not hunt down a given set of circumstances to some logical
issue. It is simply a chain of happenings, an accumulation of incident;
one episode does not grow out of another, each leading to something
deeper; but events merely succeed one another at various turns in the
road which the hero has to travel, and the only connection between them
is that they all happen to the same person. Dickens is an example of
this kind of novelist, who takes any excuse for sending his hero on his
travels, and narrates the various things that turn up on the journey.
The _Pickwick Papers_ belong to this class, for they do not represent
a scheme of action working to a certain issue, but are a chain of
episodes that never lead to anything and might continue for ever. In
the adventures of Pickwick, therefore, Dickens is really describing a
world in which his hero is wandering; just as in _David Copperfield_
he is not so much revealing a character as painting the world that
his hero passed through in his life’s journey. Such novels are really
tales of travel; the world of the story is not merely the background
for the hero, the setting for the story; rather the hero is the excuse
for describing the world. Sometimes that world is a topsy-turvy place,
like the one that bewildered Pickwick, or the fantastic “Wonderland”
that Alice found herself in; sometimes it is a Lilliput, or some
imagined future state of things, or it may even be modern society. In a
historical novel it will be some past age, described as a far-country.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account