The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
The simplest form of treatment that can be given to history in the
novel is that of the story in which the hero travels a bygone age,
and the reader follows him as into a new world and peeps over his
shoulder to see what he sees. The age, the whole scheme of things
as it then existed, is described in the adventures of the wanderer
and at its point of contact with an individual life. This happens
to some extent in every historical novel. Apart from any conscious
description of the background of his story the novelist must always be
betraying the peculiar conditions of a particular century, since the
fate and fortunes of the actors in his drama are the result of their
entanglement in the affairs of the time and in the system of things
of the particular moment. But in a work like _The Cloister and the
Hearth_ all this is raised into a method and is the way adopted for
making history betray itself; the wanderings of the hero make the book
pre-eminently a descriptive one, and the fact that the novel is rather
a chain of incident than the working out of a particular process of
action, makes the world of the story more important than the plot. The
hardships of Gerard at strange inns, his illnesses, the brawls in the
countryside, the companions whom he meets, and the steps in his career
are simply the means by which the age manifests its character, and in
them history is speaking. There can be no simpler example than this of
the translation of history into story.
In so far as this method of treating the past is followed in _The
Cloister and the Hearth_ or in any novel, it means that an age is
regarded as a set of conditions, a system of things, that is looked
upon as static and is described at its points of contact with an
individual life set in it and, so to speak, entangled in its network.
That individual may be the creation of the novelist and his chain of
adventures may be pure invention. His life is a candle that lights up
corners of his age as it is brought into them, and the places at which
he touches his age and runs up against the characteristic circumstances
of his time, his points of contact with the machinery of society,
may be ideally chosen to show up the character of his time. His life
may then sum up his age in a way in which no actual individual life
that is ever lived can in itself sum up the peculiar conditions of
the age in which it is set. In _The Cloister and the Hearth_, at any
rate, a century is fixed for us as a picture, as a static thing. The
cinematograph-film of history is stopped there, and one particular
photograph on the reel is projected into the book.
All this, however, is elaborated when the set of conditions to be
described is regarded not as a static thing, but as dynamic. _Barnaby
Rudge_, by reason of its very faults, perhaps more than by virtue of
any greatness, is an example well calculated to illustrate this point.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account