The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
But this does not span the full range of this kind of novel; it omits
something that historical novelists almost always go out of their way
to achieve. Here the incidents and adventure of the novel may be purely
fictitious, and the characters may be inventions; and only the world in
which they are placed, the currents that sweep over their lives, and
the movements that overwhelm them need to be real; the novel is true
to the life of the past, and is faithful to the age with which it is
concerned, regarding the age as a set of conditions to be conformed
with. It is true to the spirit of the age; and may describe the past
as a far-country; but it may have nothing to do with the actual events
of the past, and with history regarded as a chain of story. Every
happening that it relates may be an invention; and it can do all that
has just been claimed for it without containing any specific incident
that ever took place. It may tell its history by revealing history
in its workings in an imaginary life set in it; in the same way as
a teacher may illustrate the force of gravity to children by talking
about its workings on an imaginary apple. It may be in a way true to
history without being true to fact.
If a story is told us about some spot with which we are acquainted,
then, although the story may not be true, it touches us somewhere, it
has a root in actuality and so makes us listen, in a way which would
be impossible if the story were told, so to speak, in the air. If we
hear some anecdote that is narrated about a friend of ours it holds us
even if we know it is a legend, in a way which it could not do if it
had not fastened itself upon something real. If a story can plant one
foot in actuality then it belongs no more to the clouds, and it gains
an added power from having established a connection with reality. It is
this kind of additional effectiveness that historical novelists seek
to obtain. They are not satisfied that the world of their story shall
be true to the world of the past, and that situations and incident
shall grow out of that world. Their novel is not merely background, but
story, and to them history is not merely the world as it once was, but
also a quarry of incident. And once a novel is regarded as a story, and
incidents or episodes are looked upon as the important thing, the units
in it, the things into which the chapters arrange themselves--then a
historical novel is still “in the air,” and is only historical in a
vague and unconvincing way, and lacks one of the strongest roots in
actuality, if its events are fictitious and its characters imaginary,
so that nothing in the story ever really “happened.” There is a great
difference between the novel that simply lights up the history of an
age, and illustrates the conditions of the time, and one which is
itself a piece of historical narrative. It is when the reader can feel
that the things that are being related actually took place, and that
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account