The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
the man about whom the stories are being told really lived although
the stories about him may not all be true; it is when the thread of
incident in the novel, as well as what might be called the texture
of the book, can in some way be called “historical,” that the work
is most effective in its grip on actuality. And if this is true, an
author looking at the life of the past and at the things that happened
in history is like the artist looking upon a scene in nature and
“longing to do something with it,” longing to turn it into something
and to recreate it, in such a way as to express himself as well as to
reproduce actuality.
In _A Tale of Two Cities_, then, Dickens was content to describe the
grim fires of the French Revolution not directly, but in the reflection
that they threw upon a few imaginary individuals; the events that were
“historical” in the sense of being memorable, the public events that
held the stage at the time, he was content to portray in their effects
upon the homely lives of one or two fictitious characters. But there
is a more direct and pointed way of transferring things from history
into the novel, and this method, when superimposed upon the other,
gives a story an added link with actuality. In any novel adventures and
incidents, exploits, intrigues, and fine action rich with character
may not merely be good fiction, but coming direct from history may be
like the cords which bound Gulliver in Lilliput, each of them a tie
holding the novel to earth, and fixing it in reality. To people for
whom incident is an important thing in the novel the historical value
of _The Cloister and the Hearth_ lies not so much in the picture that
it gives of an age of the past, as in the foundation that its story
can claim to possess in the life of the Father of Erasmus. In _Barnaby
Rudge_ it is the description of Lord George Gordon and his circle that
gives the novel a tangible connection with history; the story becomes
a story about somebody we know, a person we have met before; history
provides the writer not merely with the world of his story, but with
actual story itself. It is regarded not merely as a picture of things
as they once were, but as a store of narrative and of anecdote too.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account