The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
of personal things in history, it regards man’s life as a whole and
runs his private action and his public conduct into each other, as it
ought to do; and it turns the whole into a study of human nature.
Even when dealing with an action that seems purely political it will
root the action in personality, not merely in politics. Because every
public action that was ever taken can be regarded as the private act,
the personal decision of somebody, historic events can become materials
for the novel, in spite of the fact that public affairs and political
matters are not in themselves issues for a novel.
The novelist looking at a historic figure sees personality where the
scientific historian is tempted to see only the incarnation of a
policy. He feels flesh and blood where the ordinary history-reader
complains that he is given only abstractions. Every historic decision
that comes under his review has for him a context in the mind of the
man who made it and not simply in the politics of the day. Behind every
great name he sees a human being, with a peculiar experience of life;
even if history does not tell of the experience he knows it is there,
he thinks it into history and endows the man with it, and he completes
the personality in his imagination, bringing in fiction to supply what
history fails to give. That is true resurrection, that is the reason
why historical novels are full of life and of people, where history is
often bloodless and dead.
It is evident from all this that there are particular periods and
particular problems in history that are specially adapted to this kind
of novel-treatment. An age of riotous individualism and of aggressive
personalities is more suited to it than one in which corporate action
determines events. An age in which war is a game, an orgy of fun and
fine fighting, is better than one in which war is an intricate and
organised science. A king who governs by whim is more fitting than a
politician who is merely the mouthpiece of a party, the servant of
organised action. More and more as life increases in complexity and the
world becomes organised on impersonal lines, the historical novel that
treats of the action of personalities in history and the interaction
of private life and public events, must find its course intricate
and hard. Ultimately personality counts to-day as much as ever it
did in history; it is still the real power, but its influence is not
direct, and immediate, and palpable; things perhaps can be traced back
to the influence of individuals, but it is an ultimate influence,
an influence in the last resort, and it does not show itself on the
surface of life. It is fairly true to say that the historical novel,
where it deals with politics and public events, must seize upon those
periods of history and those phases of life in which personality not
only matters in the last resort, but makes an immediate impression and
stamps itself directly upon the world. The mental struggle of Charles
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account