The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
The things that are far-reaching and historic are not to him more
important than the things that are momentary yet external. He would
give more to catch a real glimpse of Mary Queen of Scots tapping her
foot in a moment of impatience than to possess a logical statement of
her political position at any time. He will not ignore the politics of
some Prime Minister of a former century, but he would love still more
to surprise him at play. A great political speech might come within the
scope of his work, but where a historian might be tempted to sum up
the whole event in terms of politics, he would notice too the headache
that made the statesman depressed and the heat of the building that
made him irritable, the private worries that he could not throw off and
that tormented his mind and perverted his judgment, and the sight of
a man sitting opposite whom he detested in private life and who wore
an annoying tie. The novelist would attempt to recapture the moment,
rather than to estimate its historic significance, and the things which
he would notice would be those which influenced the man at the moment,
though they did not always concern the politics.
There was once a day when kingdoms were a piece of family property that
could be sold, and the whole politics of a land depended on marriages,
and wars raged for years over some intricate point in a genealogical
table; in those days public events were part of the private concern
of a king, and as surely as the succession to a throne depended upon
family inheritance, the affairs of the kingdom depended upon personal
whims and private ambitions. There was a time when the religious system
of England had to be changed because a king wished to marry a lady
about his court. In the world that Dumas described so well, personal
prowess and individual exploits determined events, and private concerns
and the prejudices and feuds of families cut across the larger history
of a nation. There have been times when a slight offered to a king’s
mistress has been more tragic in its results than a lost battle or
a lost election; and who knows how much the history of a reign has
been affected by an influence like that which Buckingham had upon
Charles I, or the Duchess of Marlborough upon Queen Anne? In all these
things private life complicates even where it does not determine
public events, and all history is full of imaginable situations like
these that invite novel-treatment. When personality counts in public
affairs, and many things, other than purely political motives--even
things which seem trivial and accidental--determine the conduct of a
man at any time, then the mood of a moment, the personal discomfort
or family irritation that might have caused it, the perversities of
whim and arbitrary desire, and a hundred other things in a man may
affect history. The historical novel, not consciously perhaps, but
still demonstrably stands for this fact. It emphasises the influence
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account