The history of the psychoanalytic movement — John Shaqi
The history of the psychoanalytic movementFreud, Sigmund
History
The history of the psychoanalytic movement
Freud, Sigmund
Psychoanalysis -- History
Adler’s most serious deviations from the reality of observation and his
deepest confusion of ideas have arisen in his attempt to correlate the
basic principle of his theory with the psychic life of the child, an
attempt which has become inevitable in psychoanalysis. The biological,
social, and physiological meaning of “masculine” and “feminine” have
here become mixed into a hopeless composition. It is quite impossible,
and it can easily be disproved by observation, that the masculine or
feminine child builds its plan of life on any original undervaluation of
the feminine sex; nor is it conceivable that a child can take as the
guiding line the wish: “I will be a real man.” In the beginning no child
has even an inkling of the significance of the difference in sex, more
likely it starts with the assumption that both sexes possess the same
(male) genital. It does not begin its sexual investigation with the
problem of sex differentiation and is far from entertaining the social
undervaluation of the woman. There are women in whose neurosis the wish
to be a man never played any part. So far as the “masculine protest” is
concerned, it can easily be traced back to a disturbance of the original
narcissism caused by the threat of castration; that is, to the first
hindrance of sexual activity. All dispute as to the psychogenesis of the
neuroses must ultimately be decided in the sphere of the childhood
neuroses. The careful analysis of a neurosis of the early years of
childhood puts an end to all mistakes in regard to the etiology of the
neuroses, and all doubts as to the part played by the sexual impulses.
That is why Adler in his criticism of Jung’s “Conflicts of the Child’s
Mind” was obliged to resort to the imputation that the material of the
case surely must have followed a uniform new tendency “from the
father.”[19]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account