The history of the psychoanalytic movementFreud, Sigmund
History
The history of the psychoanalytic movement
Freud, Sigmund
Psychoanalysis -- History
Just as deplorable and devoid of substance is all that Adler has said
about the dream—that shibboleth of psychoanalysis. At first he
considered the dream as a turning from the masculine to the feminine
line, which simply means translating the theory of wish-fulfillment in
dreams into the language of the “masculine protest.” Later he found that
the essence of the dream lies in the fact that it enables man to realize
unconsciously what is denied him consciously. Adler should also be
credited with the priority of confounding the dream with the latent
dream-thoughts, on the cognition of which rests his idea of “prospective
tendency.” Maeder followed him in this, later on. In doing so he readily
overlooks the fact that every interpretation of the dream which really
tells nothing comprehensible in its manifest appearance rests upon the
same dream interpretation, whose assumptions and conclusions he is
disputing. Concerning resistance Adler asserts that it serves to
strengthen the patient against the physician. This is certainly correct.
It means as much as saying that it serves the resistance. But whence
this resistance originates, and how it happens that its phenomena serve
the patient’s interest, these questions, as if of no interest for the
ego, are not further discussed by Adler. The detailed mechanisms of
symptoms and phenomena, the motivation of the variety of diseases and
morbid manifestations, find no consideration at all with Adler, since
everything is equally subservient to the “masculine protest,” to the
self-assertion, and to the exaltation of the personality. The system is
finished, at the expense of an extraordinary labor of new
interpretation, yet it has not contributed a single new observation. I
believe that I have succeeded in showing that his system has nothing
whatever in common with psychoanalysis.
The picture which one derives from Adler’s system is founded entirely
upon the impulse of aggression. It has no place at all for love. One
might wonder that such a cheerless aspect of life should have received
any notice whatever; but we must not forget that humanity, oppressed by
its sexual needs, is prepared to accept anything, if only the
“overcoming of sexuality” is held out as bait.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account