The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 2, October, 1909Various
History
The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 2, October, 1909
Various
History -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals; Social sciences -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals
The authors have thrown to the winds the recommendations of the
Committee of Seven, and do not try to make their book fit into any
four years’ course as now outlined for high schools. The first volume
begins with the reign of Louis XIV; and from that moment the reader’s
eye is constantly directed forward to the present moment, so that
he can read intelligently the dispatches from Europe in his morning
newspaper. Much of the traditional matter is omitted in order to
give fuller treatment to those subjects which are most important for
an understanding of the present. This leads to an arrangement and a
placing of emphasis which often seems arbitrary and unhistorical,--as,
for instance, the scant half dozen pages given to the whole reign of
Napoleon III, or the insertion in each volume of a score of pages on
natural science. It is, of course, desirable to have the pupil have
some knowledge of the development and influence of such fundamental
subjects as evolution, bacteriology and the atomic theory; but it is
unwise to put these things in a text-book of history. Few teachers at
present could teach these pages properly; and efficiency of instruction
is likely to be weakened in any institution where instructors trespass
on each others’ fields. This criticism, however, does not apply to the
remarkable chapter on the Industrial Revolution and to the excellent
pages on socialism, colonial expansion, Russo-Japanese relations and
other timely topics of present-day interest; all of these may properly
be taught by the teacher of history.
The authors have made a text-book which is accurate, lucid, packed with
information, and, at the same time, extremely readable. It has already
been used in some college courses, and evokes real enthusiasm from the
students. They feel they are learning things which are of practical
value and are up to date.
Probably this text-book, at present at any rate, is better adapted for
college than for high school use. But schools of business or commerce
could very profitably use it. Ordinary high schools should have it in
the school library for collateral reading, but could not adopt it as a
text-book until they are ready to readjust their history curriculum so
as to give much more time than at present to Modern European History.
Perhaps that time is not far distant.
[“The Development of Modern Europe.” By James Harvey Robinson and
Charles A. Beard. Two volumes; pp. xi, 362; vii, 448. Boston, 1908:
Ginn & Co.]
American History in the Secondary School
ARTHUR M. WOLFSON, PH.D., Editor.
THE INFLUENCE OF OLIVER CROMWELL AND WILLIAM III ON AMERICAN HISTORY.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account