The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, November, 1909 — John Shaqi
The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, November, 1909Various
History
The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, November, 1909
Various
History -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals; Social sciences -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals
What Dr. Stubbs said many years ago about the difficulty of mastering
the history of institutions applies with equal force to the mastery
of present institutions, especially in actual operation. Perhaps, in
a way, the student of government is more fortunately situated than
the student of history, for he can use the laboratory method to some
extent. He may attend primaries and caucuses, visit the State capital
or the City Hall, take a place among the spectators in a police court
watching the daily grind, or observe the selectman, perhaps a drug
clerk, superintend the construction of a town highway. But in the
class-room instruction in government and politics must perforce deal
largely with abstractions. The historians, long ago recognizing the
vice of unreality which attended them like a ghost that would not be
downed, cast about for some new method that would give more firmness
and life to their instruction. In their search they came upon the
sources, and instead of listening always to the voice of Green or
Stubbs, they stopped to hear the voices of the kings, monks, warriors
and lawyers who helped to make the history of which Green and Stubbs
wrote. The result, as all the world knows, has been marvelous. It has
brought more vividness and solidity to historical instruction. It has
done more. The very method itself, in the hands of skilled workers, has
become a discipline of the highest value. Whoever doubts it should read
Professor Fling’s article in the first issue of this magazine. Lawyers
likewise have discovered the same difficulties which the teachers of
history encountered, and, flinging away Blackstone and the text-books,
they have sought refuge in the sources alone. Perhaps they have gone
too far with the “case system”; in fact, a reaction seems imminent at
this moment; but the commentators will never recover their former sway.
Strange to say, teachers of government and politics have not yet made
any widespread use of the methods that have been found so effective
in the hands of other students of institutions, and yet in quantity,
variety and interest the sources available for their work are
practically unlimited. One of the most important groups of materials,
the government publications, can be had for the asking; and our waste
baskets are filled with the examples of another group, the fugitive
literature of party politics. Acres of diamonds have been at our door,
but our instruction in government and politics wears, in general, such
a barren aspect that keen-sighted students are aware of its unreality
and, slow-switted ones find no delight or profit in it. No word in our
curriculum suggests such innocuous futility as “civics,” and yet we are
preparing citizens for service in a democracy!
But to turn from preachments to some practical advice, which, I take
it, is what the editor wanted when he asked me to do this article. The
source materials for government and politics fall readily into four
groups.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account