The Idiot: His Place in Creation, and His Claims on SocietyBateman, Frederick, Sir
Science
The Idiot: His Place in Creation, and His Claims on Society
Bateman, Frederick, Sir
Mental retardation; Stupidity
The average brain weight in man may be said to range from 40 to 52-1/2
ounces, and in women from 35 to 37-1/2 ounces; the question of the
increase in size and weight of the brain, in proportion to
intellectual power, is by no means determined; statistics exist of the
weight of 23 eminent men, the list being headed by Cuvier, the
naturalist, whose brain weighed 64-1/2 ounces, whilst that of the
orator, Gambetta, weighed only 39 ounces, being much below the average
weight in the adult male; an imbecile died at the Montrose Asylum,
whose brain weighed 63 ounces, and the heaviest brain on record, which
weighed 67 ounces, was that of a bricklayer, who could neither read
nor write; it must therefore be conceded that no definite statement
can be made as to the relation that brain weight has to
intelligence.[19]
It was formerly supposed that idiots always presented some obvious
malformation of the cranium or skull. This is by no means necessarily
the case; one of the most remarkable cases of idiocy that has come
under my notice was that of a child with a well-formed head,
remarkably handsome face, and a well-proportioned body.
Dr. Ireland says, "the principal anomalies met with in the skull of
genetic idiots are flatness of the head behind, a rapid
slope of the clivus, an osseous rim round the foramen magnum,
unsymmetrical size of the cavities on each side, irregularities in the
wings of the sphenoid, and differences in the size and shape of the
jugular and other foramina; but these appearances are not constant,
and often the skull is quite regular, both in structure and
capacity."[20]
One of the most noted writers on the subject, after stating that a
number of scientific men had spent thirty years in measuring and
weighing the heads of idiots, sums up their conclusions as follows:--
1st. There is no constant relation between the development of the
cranium and the degree of intelligence.
2nd. The dimensions of the anterior part of the cranium, and
especially of the forehead, are, at least, as great among idiots as
others.[21]
3rd. Three-fifths of idiots have larger heads than men of ordinary
intelligence.
4th. There is no constant relation between the degree of intelligence
and the weight of the brain.[22]
5th. Sometimes the brain of idiots presents no deviation in form,
colour, and density from the normal standard; it is, in fact,
perfectly normal.
After such a statement as this, I can readily imagine that some of you
may say, it seems to us that you doctors really know but little about
the genesis of idiocy. I am afraid this is, to some extent, true. We
are only on the threshold of inquiry, and science of to-day is unable
to bridge over the gulf that separates matter from mind.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account