The Idiot: His Place in Creation, and His Claims on Society — John Shaqi
The Idiot: His Place in Creation, and His Claims on SocietyBateman, Frederick, Sir
Science
The Idiot: His Place in Creation, and His Claims on Society
Bateman, Frederick, Sir
Mental retardation; Stupidity
Not only in the 16th century, but certain philosophers of a later date
have questioned the idiot's place in creation, and have disputed
his right to be classed among the human family; and some
scientists--believers in the so-called doctrine of Evolution, as
applied to the Descent of Man--have gone so far as to pretend that the
brain of the microcephalic idiot is so far removed from the human
type, as to constitute him a connecting link between man and the
anthropoid apes! Now, the interesting results of our training
institutions, showing _the capacity for progressive improvement_ which
exists in the idiot, gives the lie to this absurd and purely
sensational hypothesis.
Here let me add that I strongly deprecate introducing the _odium
theologicum_ into the discussion of this subject, being fully
conscious of the futility of attempting to check an unwelcome or
distasteful theory by means of ecclesiastical censures; and I further
admit that in anything like a scientific demonstration of truth, an
appeal to the affections would be absurdly out of place.[36] Moreover,
I should not reject the Darwinian theory from any sensational notion
that its adoption was derogatory to Man's dignity, and I fully echo
the sentiment of the naturalist who said that he would prefer being
descended from a good honest monkey, than to be obliged to avow
himself the offspring of certain fanatical enemies of scientific
knowledge and progress; but I do complain of the tendency of the
present day to accept new ideas without knowing or caring how to sift
them. Everything is hypothetical, and allowed to enter the mind
through the ivory gate of fancy; and on purely hypothetical premises,
an attempt is made to found conclusive arguments. Strip the assertions
of all their vagueness and superficial varnish, and reduce them to a
skeleton of logical statement, and we shall see how much is assumed
and how little is proved; and we shall find that we are asked to
accept a chain of hypotheses, as if it were an induction founded on
ascertained and indisputable facts. In thus expressing myself, I wish
to add that the ultimate goal of the scientist is the establishment of
truth, and I should as soon attempt to stop the progress of the
avalanche that has become dislodged from the mountain top, as to try
to bar the path of scientific progress, or to extinguish the torch of
discovery. The tide of scientific truth will continue to flow on in
spite of the modern Canutes, who may utter from time to time their
imperial commands to stay its course. _Magna est veritas et
prevalebit._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account